Trump cut off Israel. Good, that only makes Jerusalem stronger

AP26291551882349.jpg


President Donald Trump recently announced that the $4 billion that has been annually transferred from the U.S. to Israel will stop at the beginning of 2027. This notification took place in early November 2026, right before the midterm elections. Thus, it was not a result of this ballot box occurrence, although it may well have been an attempt to garner more votes for the Republican Party. Judging from the gigantic blue wave that took place then, this was a wise decision on Trump’s part.

What are the benefits and costs for the two nations involved in that decision? I address this question under four headings.

What are the costs to the U.S. from Trump’s initiative?​


One of the most important detriments will be that America’s most important and most loyal ally will no longer be able to provide it with the level of protection it did before this financial cancellation. Make no mistake about it: The Israeli military does indeed provide defense services to its senior partner. The IDF delivers protection in the form of intelligence (by no means limited to that pertaining only to the Middle East); it tests U.S. military equipment not just theoretically but under actual wartime conditions.

What are the benefits to the U.S. from this cessation of subsidies?​


It all depends on how this donor country spends these new funds, as to whether there are any benefits at all. If this country follows the Argentinian pattern, blazed by President Javier Milei, and reduces taxation, other things equal, all will be well. Free enterprise will have received a much-needed shot in the arm, for the betterment of the entire U.S. population.

On the other hand, if these funds are utilized so as to promote socialism, greater government ownership of U.S. companies (e.g., Intel), or economic fascism (more and more intrusive regulations like rent control, minimum wages, antitrust), then the U.S. would have been better off if these funds were to continue to be given to Israel, or emptied into the bottom of the sea. Then, these transfers should be placed into the previous category, harms.

Debits to Israel​


An annual $4 billion dollars ain’t hay. Add it up over the years, and this amounts to real money. The IDF would have made good use of these funds so as to better defend Israel against the continual and unwarranted attacks to which it has been subject ever since its inception in 1948.

Furthermore, a two-month notice is more than a little abrupt. The Israeli military had been expecting a continuation of these subsidies for the long run. It was predicting no such alteration. It will now have to engage in some radical scrambling of its budget. None of this will help its security.

Benefits to the only civilized country in the Middle East​


At first glance, this category would have appeared to be a null set. Superficially, it might seem seriously difficult to see any benefit whatsoever to the recipient nation when the spigot is turned off. But this is mistaken. There are indeed advantages, serious ones, for Israel in this regard.

First of all, it will encourage this nation to remove its head from a lower part of its body politic. It will have to, once again, learn and relearn that it cannot rely upon the proverbial “kindness of strangers.” It must be self-reliant to a greater degree.

Eisenhower demonstrated this by in effect compelling Israel to exit from the Sinai, which it had won, fair and square, in a defensive war. Democrats, too, followed suit. Obama, and Biden afterward, took Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “out to the woodshed” for verbal spankings. These complaints concerned the IDF’s supposed “over the top” response to the atrocity of Oct. 7, 2023. And now, yet another Republican demonstrates this phenomenon by cutting off Israel at its financial knees. This is a bipartisan practice of which Israel must become even more cognizant in the future.

But there is perhaps an even more important benefit for Israel on this occasion. It is said that the army “travels on its stomach.” If so, it is even more true that the entire country, military included, travels on the basis of its economy.

How is Israel doing on this matter? Not too well. It started out in 1948 as an almost totally socialist economy. It is a miracle it was able to defend itself, given that it had very little support from its economy (this shows that other phenomenon, too, beside a strong economy, contribute to military might). Thanks to the Likud Party, and to the Herculean efforts of Netanyahu, Israel has been dragged, kicking and screaming, away from its socialist roots. But it still has a long, long way to go in this direction if the economy is to contribute maximally to national defense. It is not even yet in the top quartile of countries in terms of economic freedom and free enterprise. According to the Fraser and Cato Institutes, Oman, Qatar, and the United Arab Emirates all rank above Israel in terms of economic freedom. If that is not a disgrace, there is no such thing as a disgrace.

If this cessation of that $4 billion serves as a kick in the Israeli pants, and it seriously moves that country in the direction of laissez-faire capitalism, Trump will have immeasurably strengthened Israel’s ability to defend itself.

Hopefully, the next time the IDF needs a bunker-buster bomb to deal with Iranian nuclear ambitions, and the airplanes sufficient to land it where it will do the most good, it will not have to call upon anyone else for such a mission.

There is yet another benefit to Israel from Trump’s recent decision. It is safe to say that previously, the IDF has fought its defensive battles with one hand tied behind its back. Half the time, when planning military strategy, it has had to keep in mind not only the best tactics, but, also, what Big Brother America would have to say about them; what will be the effect on the U.S. Congress, its presidency, if it pursues this strategy, or that one. I don’t say that no vestige of this handicap will still prevail, but, surely, it will bite less effectively.

THE ISRAELI SOLDIERS WHO DIED AS GAZA’S LIFEGUARDS

Israel will also benefit, albeit indirectly, from Trump’s parsimony. American and other diaspora Jews will also gain; I don’t say there will be no more besmirching of them on this dual loyalty charge. But, surely, it will decrease. Why include this under the category of “benefits to Israel?” That is because, like it or not, Israel is the home base, the last resort, of every other Jew on the planet. If there were an Israel in 1939, the plight of German, Polish, and other Jews might well have been greatly lessened. Nowadays, with what is occurring in England, France, and Canada, and, most importantly, with the advent of the Democratic Socialists of America, it is imperative that these members of the Hebrew background have an insurance policy. Israel is precisely that insurance policy.

By the way, the U.S. gives military aid to other counties too. Why cut, only, that emanating to Israel, all of a sudden?

Walter E. Block is the Harold E. Wirth eminent scholar, endowed chairman and professor of economics at Loyola University New Orleans.

Continue reading...

[ H/T Washington Examiner ]

Comments

There are no comments to display
Back
Top