Why evangelical voters will decide the 2028 GOP nominee

029c4ca324319c70123c5d25ee0a56c9-e1794601477637.jpg


One of the few bright spots for the Republican Party in this month’s midterm elections is that evangelical voters stayed firmly in their camp even as the nation drifted left and Democrats regained control of Congress.

Among religious groups, white evangelical voters turned out the strongest for the GOP, even without President Donald Trump on the ballot. Exit polls showed they voted for the Republican Party at 82%, higher than 59% of Protestants and 20% of Catholics.

The data reaffirm they’re the backbone of the Republican coalition, and they’re poised to again exert their influence in determining the next GOP presidential nominee.

“Evangelicals are the single most loyal and reliable constituency in the electorate for the Republican Party, and without them, the big tent becomes a pup tent,” said Ralph Reed, Faith & Freedom Coalition chairman. “There is probably no path to the presidential nomination in 2028 without winning at least a plurality of these voters.”

Trump remains an iconic figure in the GOP, akin to former President Ronald Reagan, and many leaders who spoke to the Washington Examiner were uncertain anyone could replace his influence in the 2028 race.

Evangelicals “want a fighter,” said Reed. “They do want somebody who’s going to be a champion for them. And in that sense, they’re not necessarily looking for another Trump, but they are going to want somebody who’s willing to fight, especially after Tuesday.”

After Democrats gained 55 Senate seats and more than 250 House seats, evangelicals have begun voicing concern about how the next standard-bearer will handle issues such as American support for Israel, the Iran war, illegal immigration, and, of utmost importance, limiting abortions nationwide.

The war has dragged down Trump’s approval ratings, and if it doesn’t improve, it could also drag down the Republican presidential nominee again, some Republicans suggested.

“To state the blindingly obvious, the Trump administration needs to get more popular if Republicans are going to have any chance in 2028, and the only way to do that is a laser focus on the cost of living to the exclusion of everything else,” said GOP pollster Patrick Ruffini.

For evangelicals, though, biblical issues, and to a lesser extent the war, will color their vote for the 2028 GOP nominee.

Support for Israel remains high for evangelical voters, who cite Jesus’s Jewish background as part of their unwavering support. A July Pew Research poll showed 74% of white evangelicals and 55% of non-white evangelicals have a favorable view of Israel.

The Trump administration’s handling of the war and its decision to nix roughly $4 billion in annual military aid to Israel by the end of this year could saddle Vice President JD Vance, the current front-runner, in the 2028 primary race.

The developments have other candidates casting their own shadow primaries.

Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) has signaled slight disagreements with the administration that could help him if he runs. He is a staunch Israel defender and has called out former Fox News host Tucker Carlson for his anti-Israel comments. On Cruz’s podcast this week, he predicted that War Secretary Pete Hegseth “will resign voluntarily or Trump will fire him. Or, if that does not happen, I think it is extremely likely, if not certain, that the House will impeach him.” He also opposed Trump imposing “Liberation Day” tariffs, an issue the public did not support, according to polls.

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has been on an unofficial tour touting Florida Republicans’ successes in staving off the blue wave. He is also reportedly laying the groundwork to launch a conservative think tank and hasn’t completely shut the door on a 2028 run.

Long-shot candidate Chris Christie has hinted he could also run for president again after the GOP’s rout last week.

“The Trump era is over,” Christie said just days after the midterm elections. “And we need to look forward to new leadership in our party and our country.”

Other possible 2028 candidates have hinted that cultural issues such as abortion could be their path to the nomination.

“As a Congress, when you choose to fund Planned Parenthood, but you cut Medicaid, when you choose to fund transgender surgeries for minors but you cut real healthcare spending. When you abandon pro-lifers, when you abandon the poor, when you abandon the needy, when you abandon working people, you’re going to get your butt kicked, and you’re going to deserve it,” Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) told reporters about the GOP losses.

He also called for “a time of fasting and prayer for the nation” next month to reflect on the GOP’s midterm rout.

Hawley previously said he wouldn’t run in 2028; the midterm results could cause him to give it a second thought.

“Since the midterms went the way they went, I think the field for 2028 could be quite large, and I think evangelicals are not a whole lot different than the regular voter,” said Bob Vander Platts, an evangelical activist and head of the Family Leader in Iowa. “They’re really going to want to see somebody who’s got a fresh vision for the country that’s based on conservative principles and common sense leadership, and somebody that’s authentic and has a history of getting things done.”

Iowa holds the first nominating contests for the GOP presidential primary and is home to an influential evangelical population that will decide which candidate has momentum after it holds its caucuses in 2027.

Former Vice President Mike Pence told the Washington Examiner‘s Peter Laffin that the GOP is facing a crisis as it has lost its focus on issues such as abortion under Trump.

“What is lesser known is that we’ve seen the rise of populist right voices, of isolationism, of protectionism, of marginalizing values like the right to life, and I think we’ve got to have that conversation,” Pence said of the 2028 race.

“I think we’ve got to engage in a thorough debate,” he said. “And so, when I think of what remains of my bully pulpit, I want to use whatever opportunity we have to make the case for returning the Republican Party to the broad mainstream conservative agenda that’s defined our movements from the Reagan administration through the first Trump administration, because candidly, if we don’t get the Republican Party back to being the party of broad mainstream conservative values and principles, it won’t matter who we nominate in 2028.”

During the 2024 presidential race, Vance successfully pressured other GOP candidates to embrace a 15-week federal abortion ban. Under Trump’s second administration, many social conservatives have lamented the rise in medication abortions four years after Roe v. Wade was struck down.

Kelsey Pritchard, spokeswoman for Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America, told the Washington Examiner the lack of enthusiasm from the Trump administration depressed anti-abortion voters from casting a ballot and could do so again in 2028. SBA Pro-Life America is not an evangelical group but has overlaps with evangelicals who want to limit abortions.

“The issue isn’t that evangelicals are gonna turn out in droves for the Democrats. I think it’s the issue that they’re just not gonna turn out like we saw this last election,” Pritchard said. “And Republicans can’t win without the pro-life vote. So, what we’ve been calling for is for whoever’s running in 2028, from the top of the ticket to the bottom, that you be pro-life and that you explain your position and you expose Democratic extremism on the issue. You can’t just forget that this huge bloc of voters, because the people who vote pro-life are actually even a stronger Republican indicator than evangelical voters.”

Anti-abortion activists also have to contend that voters “approved two out of the three state ballot measures protecting abortion rights and rejected an anti-abortion measure in Missouri,” this cycle, according to the Guttmacher Institute. Another measure in Idaho that would have provided a legal pathway to overturn the state’s total abortion ban failed.

ANTI-ABORTION ACTIVISTS FEAR TRUMP WON’T HOLD THE LINE WITH DEMOCRATIC CONGRESS

Where candidates stand on the issues may not matter, however, if Trump decides to get involved in the primary.

“They have a decadelong relationship essentially with this guy, and once he concludes the apprentice-style nomination contest and decides who he wants his successor to be, I’m sure a lot of them will fall in line,” said Patrick T. Brown, a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center, where he writes on family policy. “But there’s going to be plenty of competition for that before that happens.”

David Sivak contributed to this story.

Continue reading...

[ H/T Washington Examiner ]

Comments

There are no comments to display
Back
Top