Victor Davis Hanson: The Problem With the New American Right, Part 1

261118-Tucker_Carlson.jpg


Editor’s note: This is a lightly edited transcript of today’s video from Daily Signal senior contributor Victor Davis Hanson. Subscribe to our YouTube channel to see more of his videos.

Hello, this is Victor Davis Hanson for the Daily Signal.

We live in very confusing times. Let’s start with the Right or the Republicans or the conservatives. Who is what and what is who?

Well, let’s break down the people who now sort of identify as conservative, as right. There was originally Never Trumpers.

That was one part of the party. These were the people who had believed in free and unfettered trade, basically open borders, abortion on demand. They really didn’t want to get into cultural issues. They did believe in libertarian free market economy and, you could say, strong defense. Not now. The Never Trumpers are really in two branches.

The most extreme are what I would call the apostate Never Trumpers. These are people who hated MAGA to such a degree, and Donald Trump in particular, that they have gone full bore left-wing in response.

So you have people like George Will now who endorse Democratic candidates. You have people in The Bulwark, especially Bill Kristol and his associates, who are endorsing Zohran Mamdani and Abdul El-Sayed.

So they’re no longer in the Right. They are not just Democrats. They’re hard-left Democrats, and they are still consumed with Trump derangement syndrome.

But there’s another group of apostates, left Never Trumpers, and these are people who didn’t like Donald Trump. They didn’t like the MAGA movement, but they considered them better than the alternative sort of.

And they go between 51% supporting Trump and 49%. They’re usually very critical of Donald Trump, and they play down his successes and exaggerate his deficiency because they feel he deviated from the George Bush, John McCain, Bob Dole, Mitt Romney gold standard of Republicanism.

And who are they? They’re people in The Wall Street Journal, people in the National Review Online, the orthodox Republican Party, the establishment Republican Party.

Notice that there’s not very many people in the establishment Republican Party in the so-called Republican Congress. That may change because of the MAGA defeats in the midterms.

But so far, it’s been remarkable that the McCain, Romney, Bob Dole, Bush wing and its advocacy of libertarian laissez-faire economics, open borders, abortion, and then they agree with Donald Trump on a number of other issues, have not been able to take the reins back and control the party as they did.

One of the reasons is that people remember that they had, not really won 51% of the vote since 1988. And candidates like George H.W. Bush and George W. Bush, who won in 2004 against John Kerry, but earlier, Bob Dole that tried to run against Bill Clinton.

And, of course, John McCain and Mitt Romney turned off about 20 million would-be Republican voters who did not come out to vote for them.

And those were won back into the fold by the MAGA people. Now, the MAGA, for now, is mainstream, but it is divided really in two.

I shouldn’t say in two. It’s disproportionately divided. I would say about 80% of them are doctrinaire Trump supporters. In foreign policy, that means they’re Jacksonians. Domestic po- policy, they’re for strict secure borders, ending the Green New Deal subsidies, fossil fuel development, taking an active stance culturally against, NPR, PBS, the media, the universities, DEI, etc.

But they have a divide on foreign policy. And I would call these people the new neo-isolationists. They disagree with the Jacksonians, the regular MAGA people in two key areas. No. 1, they are neo-isolationists. They don’t want to be involved at all overseas, even when that does not involve ground troops.

They were critical of the Trump elimination of terrorist Gen. Qasem Soleimani in the first term and Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi. They were critical of the Nicolas Maduro successful extradition. They were critical of the brief bombing in 2025 of the nuclear… They want nothing to do. They are isolationists.

They define America First not as taking care of American security, even if it means warding off potential or current enemies.

It’s just a Fortress America, attack.

And the second big issue that separates the MAGA movement is that the neo-isolationists, the new isolationists want us not just to cut off aid to Israel. Donald Trump is apparently going to do that in 2027. They want to radically change our relationship with Israel.

They feel that in the recent Oct. 7, 2023, massacre and what followed in Gaza was good evidence that we are on the wrong side of that conflict. So they, in this very strange way, support the Gazans and the Palestinians over Israel.

And the MAGA people are bewildered by this isolationist wing because after all, Israel is the only consensual free society and Western society in the Middle East surrounded by 500 million people of the Islamic faith that live in autocratic societies and are pledged in the most part to destroy Israel.

But that’s the divide. There’s two other groups in the Republican Party now, and they are even to the right of the MAGA isolationists, and that is I’d call the Carlsonites. Those are followers of Tucker Carlson.

They believe not just in the isolationist view, the J.D. Vance view of foreign policy and the suspicion of Israel, but they feel that the United States is on completely the wrong track and that they feel that we have downplayed the dangers of legal immigration, legal immigration.

That because we’re not assimilating people, in the first or second immigrant generation, that we should stop most all immigration.

A lot of people have moderate, moderated views of that, but they have a racial component to it. They believe, the Tucker Carlson people, that the country was founded by 94% people from Europe, so-called whites, and therefore we must retain that strong Christian white, indigenous identity is what they call it. They have enemies on the Right, and those are a much more ascendant group, the so-called Groypers.

These are Nick Fuentes’ people. And they agree with the Carlsonites in a lot of different ways. They go back in history and say the Jews were the problem a lot of in history. They say that World War II, we should have not joined World War II on the side of Britain, much less Russia. They rewrite that.

They have skepticism of the Holocaust. They believe Jews… they’re much more explicit than Tucker Carlson’s group about the pernicious, supposed pernicious, nature of, Jewishness in the United States. They believe that you have to be actively antisemitic and actively anti-immigrant and actively pro-white and actively, take on the Republican Party and the MAGA movement.

It’s kind of ironic that the most vehement enemies now of MAGA are not necessarily doctrinaire Democrats or people in the Democratic Socialist, even Islamist movement. It’s the Carlsonites and the Groypers especially who have delighted in the midterm defeat of the MAGA movement as if they’re saying to us, “We agree with you on the border.

We agree with you on deportations. We agree with you on the dangers of DEI. We agree with you on lowering the crime rate, and we agree with you to make America strong defensively. But because of your relationship with Israel and the Iran war, we hope you lose everything and that agenda is wiped out and the Democrats come in and the whole party blows up.

“And among the ashes, the Groyper Carlson Phoenix will arise, and a new type of conservatism will emerge.”

I think that’s delusional, but we’ll find out.

We publish a variety of perspectives. Nothing written here is to be construed as representing the views of the Daily Signal.

Continue reading...

[ H/T The Daily Signal ]

Comments

There are no comments to display
Back
Top