As he prepares to leave office, Gov. Mike DeWine, R-Ohio, may end up commuting death penalty sentences. The term-limited governor announced his opposition to capital punishment in June, drawing mixed reactions.
Last week, DeWine referenced his power as governor to commute these sentences. “The power of a governor to commute a sentence, to do something, goes back to the beginning of this country,” he said.
When DeWine voiced his opposition in June to the death penalty law signed in 1981 that he cosponsored, many of his fellow Republicans took issue, including state Rep. Brian Stewart. Although he acknowledged the governor’s authority in a statement to the Daily Signal, Stewart questioned the timing.
“Pardons and commutations are constitutional powers the governor has. However, waiting until the last month of eight years in office to override these unanimous jury verdicts seems designed to avoid any electoral accountability, and it flies in the face of the false claim that Ohioans allegedly support repeal of the death penalty for the most heinous murderers among us,” he said.
Andy Wilson, the attorney general whom DeWine named to replace Dave Yost when Yost left on June 1 to work for Alliance Defending Freedom, similarly took issue via a statement from June. Yost applauded the statement that Wilson put out at the time.
About commutations, Wilson said in June, “I’m relieved that the governor didn’t use the power of commutation to undo the decisions of the prosecutors, juries and judges who are closest to the facts and evidence in these cases.”
“Having personally handled several death penalty trials, I understand the value of the death penalty as an option for prosecutors and victims in very limited circumstances. The decision to seek the death penalty is the most serious decision a prosecutor can make. My experience working with prosecutors across the state is that they do not make this choice lightly,” Wilson added. “In a small percentage of cases, the death penalty is the only option that can bring a measure of justice and closure to the families of victims who rely on the criminal justice system to help them through the worst moments of their lives.”
DeWine had told News 5 Cleveland that he is reviewing cases when it comes to granting clemency. Although there are 104 prisoners on death row in Ohio, there has been a pause during DeWine’s tenure. Gov.-elect Amy Acton will continue that moratorium.
Acton’s Republican opponent, Vivek Ramaswamy, last month during an event at the Columbus Metropolitan Club, expressed concerns with botched executions taking place in Tennessee. However, he said he was in favor of reinstating the death penalty in specific instances.
His running mate for lieutenant governor, Ohio Senate President Rob McColley, used similar language to Stewart’s. “You look at some of the most heinous, reprehensible cases that we see that wind up with somebody being placed on death row, and they say in those circumstances, ‘How are you going to deny that kind of punishment?'” News 5 Cleveland quoted him as saying. He did, however, show a concern about ensuring the evidence is all there.
Recently in California, Gov. Gavin Newsom issued a controversial blanket commutation. That’s not a move that DeWine plans on. Any commutations will likely start with what the Ohio Parole Board recommends, as News 5 Cleveland also mentioned.
Continue reading...
[ H/T The Daily Signal ]