Summary
- Jens Soering filed a petition in February 2026 asking the Court of Appeals of Virginia to overturn his 1990 murder convictions.
- DNA testing excluded Soering from tested blood samples, while the attorney general argues the evidence does not satisfy Virginia’s legal standard.
- The appeals court will decide whether to dismiss the petition, grant relief, or hold a hearing on Soering’s actual-innocence claim.
The Jens Soering murder case is one of the most controversial and widely debated criminal cases in Virginia history.
In March 1985, Derek and Nancy Haysom were found brutally murdered in their home in Bedford County, Virginia. Both had suffered multiple stab wounds, and the crime initially appeared to be a particularly vicious double homicide.
The investigation focused on their daughter, Elizabeth Haysom, and her boyfriend, Jens Soering, a German national and a University of Virginia student.
Investigators learned that Haysom and Soering had been involved in an intense romantic relationship that her parents strongly opposed. Haysom ultimately pleaded guilty to being an accessory before the fact in her parents’ murders and received a 90-year prison sentence. Soering, meanwhile, was arrested in England in 1986 after the couple fled the United States.
He initially confessed to the murders, claiming he had killed Derek and Nancy Haysom to protect Elizabeth Haysom from the death penalty, believing his status as the son of a German diplomat might shield him from execution. He later recanted that confession, arguing that it had been fabricated to protect Haysom.
The Soering case remains controversial because several important aspects of the prosecution’s evidence have been challenged over the years, particularly the circumstances surrounding his confession, the reliability of Haysom’s testimony, and the interpretation of DNA evidence.
The Innocence Project, co-founded by Barry Scheck, a member of the “Dream Team” of lawyers assembled for the O.J. Simpson case, eventually took up the case, thanks in part to the efforts of retired Albemarle County Sheriff Chip Harding. DNA testing found that blood evidence with the same type as Soering’s did not match him. The Virginia Parole Board granted him parole in November 2019, while then-Gov. Ralph Northam denied his request for an absolute pardon.
He returned to Germany, but earlier this year, he filed a petition for a writ of actual innocence, citing new DNA evidence that he claims connects other people at the crime scene to the Haysom family.
And this is where the irony that seems to be part of the political party of “follow the science” appears.
Most of us recall that shortly after Soering’s parole, Northam issued lockdown restrictions because of the growing number of COVID-19 infections. Northam repeatedly told us that his decisions were made by “following the science.”
OK, so what has changed in the past seven years? Virginia Attorney General Jay Jones, a proud member of Northam’s “follow the science” political party, doesn’t even want it considered
You see, this week, his office filed a response to Soering’s petition, using its weight to oppose the request and arguing that “none of the evidence is new” or does not meet the legal standard to overturn Soering’s conviction.
Not being a lawyer myself, the phrasing struck me as odd.
Of course, the evidence isn’t new; the crime happened in 1985. It’s the science that is new and has freed many people from prison for crimes committed before DNA technology existed.
When lawyers like the attorney general say things like that, my antennae perk up.
We should note here that DNA science has also allowed law enforcement to catch and convict killers such as Jesse Matthew Jr. for murders that seemed unsolvable.
So, why suddenly do Virginia’s top Democrats not want to “follow the science”?
Think of it this way: If Soering is successful, the governor can give him his voting rights back.
What? Too soon?
We publish a variety of perspectives. Nothing written here is to be construed as representing the views of the Daily Signal.
Continue reading...
[ H/T The Daily Signal ]