One of the things that mightily irked the producers of the “NAZA” film was that the Israeli Defense Force killed terrorists while they were at home, thus also visiting death on their wives and innocent children. A new aphorism has been created to depict just this phenomenon: “Where’s Daddy?”
Consider the following. A man is coming at you with a knife, yelling “I’m gonna kill you!” You have a gun. You are entitled to shoot him in self-defense. If you aim for his knee, a relatively small target, you have a 50% chance of stopping him in his tracks; if you hit him, he’ll drop, but you have only a one in two probability of reaching that small a target. However, if you aim for the center of his chest, a larger area, you have a 100% chance of not only stopping him, but you will also likely kill him. If you miss his knee, he will murder you. Stipulate arguendo, that those are the only two places into which you can fire your bullet. Now, to be sure, it would be nice if you hit him in the knee. Every life is precious, even that of a would-be murderer.
The question arises, are you obligated to aim for his knee? The answer is pretty obvious: absolutely not. People who aim to murder you do not deserve anything like that sort of consideration. Yes, yes, if the chances of preventing the murder were 100% in both cases, you are obliged to do the least harm. Fine. But the odds, here, are very different.
Now, consider a different case. The IDF is attempting to kill a terrorist who murdered dozens of people on Oct. 7, 2023. He has promised to repeat this atrocity, two, three, many more times. If the Israeli military attempts to do so while he is out and about, building tunnels, setting off suicide bombers, etc., they have a 50% chance of stopping him from repeating these atrocities. However, he sleeps at home with his family. If they blow up his entire house, killing his family along with himself, they can do so with a 100% certainty. If they fail to stop him, we stipulate that he will indeed murder dozens more Israelis.
Is the IDF obligated to try to hunt him down during the day, when it will be difficult to do so? No more than you are obliged to aim for the knee of the marauder who is attacking you. It is greatly to be regretted that his innocent family will perish, but, that is his responsibility, not that of the IDF.
Let us try a different hypothetical situation. The same man is running at you, threatening your life. He has a gun, you have as gun. Only a chest shot will suffice against him. However, strapped to the front of his body are his two children, aged 1 and 3. The only way to protect yourself (and your own progeny) is to shoot him in the chest, thus killing him as well as hit totally innocent babies.
Are you obligated to cease and desist, and allow him to slaughter you and your family? Or, are you allowed, by natural law, to kill the three of them. Of course you may do so. And, who is responsible for the deaths of these precious children? It is he, not you. The guilt is entirely his, not yours by even one iota.
The Hamas fighter knows full well that the IDF has killed entire families in order to stop his colleagues. Why, then, is he endangering his family, by spending the night in his home with them? He is using them as shields!
This is something that even the Nazis, at the very end of World War II, did not do. These people are despicable beyond words.
And what can be said about the creators of the award winning “NAZA” film, who excoriated the IDF for killing these Hamas monsters, who hid behind babies and women’s skirts? Not too much, at least not in words of congratulation for a job well done. The very opposite would be no less than is justified.
Should the filmmakers be imprisoned for traitorous behavior? No. Should they lose their Israeli citizenship? No, again. Free speech and all. Israel is better than that, far better.
Continue reading...
[ H/T WorldNetDaily ]