Sunny Hostin just volunteered a stunning piece of her own history on national television.
The longtime co-host of The View said she was the lone holdout juror in the 1991 Daniel Rakowitz case — and that she persuaded the other 11 jurors to join her in finding him not criminally responsible by reason of insanity.
This was not some dry dispute over a technical charge. The victim was 26-year-old Monika Beerle, whose killing and dismemberment became one of the most grotesque crimes in New York City history.
Watch Hostin explain it in her own words:
TheWrap reports that Hostin made the revelation during a discussion of the recent Lindsay Clancy mistrial. Hostin said she identified with the power of a holdout juror because she had been one herself before attending law school.
According to the report, Hostin said the Rakowitz jury was sequestered for nine days and that one furious juror threw a chair at her. She then described challenging the other jurors one at a time until all 12 agreed on the insanity verdict.
Her own phrase was remarkable: “One by one, I picked them off.”
Hostin said she believed Rakowitz was clearly psychotic. She also stressed that he remains institutionalized, calling that confinement “a different type of prison.”
That last point matters. The insanity verdict did not put Rakowitz back on the street, and describing the outcome as though he walked free would be wrong.
But it does not make the television moment any less jarring.
UPI reported in February 1991 that the jury deliberated for nine days before finding Rakowitz not guilty of intentional murder and not responsible for depraved-indifference murder by reason of mental illness. The jury could not agree on a separate evidence-tampering count.
The report identified Beerle as a 26-year-old Swiss dance student who had wanted Rakowitz out of her East Village apartment. Prosecutors said he killed her, dismembered and boiled her body, and served some of her remains in soup to homeless people.
Police arrested Rakowitz after finding Beerle’s bones and skull in a bucket filled with cat litter at a Port Authority bus terminal storage room. During deliberations, jurors repeatedly reviewed a videotaped confession and requested readbacks of testimony from doctors who described his mental condition.
UPI also reported that Rakowitz repeatedly refused to let his own attorneys enter an insanity plea. The defense centered on mental illness anyway, and the final verdict turned on criminal responsibility rather than whether Beerle had been killed.
Whatever anyone thinks of the legal standard, Beerle must remain at the center of this story. She was not a prop in a legal debate, and the horror inflicted on her family did not disappear when the verdict was read.
A later New York court opinion confirms that Rakowitz was committed to Kirby Forensic Psychiatric Center after the 1991 verdict. The court said he had repeatedly been found to suffer from a dangerous mental disorder and had remained in the secure state hospital.
In that 2005 decision, the judge rejected Rakowitz’s request for release or transfer to a less secure facility. The court cited his continuing mental illness, history of violence, refusal to accept responsibility and the risk he would pose outside a tightly controlled setting.
So yes, the legal outcome was confinement rather than freedom. It was still the verdict Hostin says she personally drove.
And she recounted it on daytime television with a smile, laughter around the table and a description of persuading the jury that sounded more like a victory lap than a solemn memory about a murdered woman.
Even Hostin’s co-hosts looked shocked. Alyssa Farah Griffin blurted out, “And you got this guy off?” while guest host Star Jones jokingly tried to move away from Hostin at the table.
The clip spread quickly online as viewers absorbed exactly what Hostin had revealed:
There is a serious legal argument to be had about criminal responsibility, psychosis and what the insanity defense requires. Jurors are obligated to apply the law, even in cases whose facts make the stomach turn.
But there is also something deeply unsettling about hearing a national television personality tell this story as though wearing down 11 other jurors were a career credential.
The human being who paid the price was Monika Beerle.
That is the name the audience should remember after the studio laughter is gone.
Continue reading...
[ H/T WLT Report ]
