Swearing In on the Quran Is Incompatible with the U.S. Constitution and Should Be Stopped

Public officials take an oath to support and defend the United States Constitution. It is a public commitment to the supreme law of the land. Using the Quran for that ceremony sends the opposite message. It elevates a text whose political and legal teachings clash with the very rights the Constitution protects. The Quran contains rules that directly contradict core constitutional guarantees: equality under the law, free speech, freedom of religion, and the idea that the people’s Constitution is supreme. For that reason, it has no place in the official act of assuming public office.

Keith Ellison (D-Minnesota), Ilhan Omar (D-Minnesota), and Rashida Tlaib (D-Michigan) have already sworn on the Quran. Zohran Mamdani (D-New York) has done the same as mayor of New York City. Abdul El-Sayed (D-Michigan) has publicly announced he will swear on the Quran when he takes his Senate seat. The Founders would be shocked this is being allowed. It never should have happened, and the practice should end now.


Where is Congress? Where are our state legislators? Where is President Trump? Why is no one putting a stop to this?

Jefferson’s Quran Was Not an Endorsement


Critics often point to Thomas Jefferson’s copy of the Quran as if it proved early American approval of Islam as a governing system. The record shows something different. Jefferson bought George Sale’s 1734 English translation in 1765 while he was a law student in Williamsburg. He treated it as a work of comparative law, one book among many on natural law, religion, and legal systems. He acquired it more than a decade before the Declaration of Independence and long before the Barbary pirate problem. He later kept it with other texts on religion and jurisprudence. Owning the book reflected his interest in understanding other systems. It was never an endorsement of their political claims.

His knowledge of the Quran proved useful when the young United States confronted the Barbary states, which attacked American merchant ships and murdered, enslaved, tortured, or held their crews for ransom. During the Barbary Wars, the North African Muslim states of Algiers, Tunis, Tripoli, and others demanded regular tribute from foreign powers as the price of safe passage for their ships and the freedom of their crews. These annual payments amounted to a systematic form of extortion.

In 1786, Jefferson and John Adams met the Tripoli ambassador in London. They asked why Muslim pirates attacked nations that had done them no harm. Recently Florida Governor Ron DeSantis correctly pointed to their report of the meeting to John Jay:

“According to the account from Jefferson and Adams, the ambassador said the attacks were based on the laws of the Muslim prophet as written in the Quran. The founders reported that nations refusing to acknowledge Muslim authority were considered sinners who could be attacked and enslaved.” [1]

The ambassador’s answer matched classical readings of Quranic verses on warfare against non-Muslims, including Surah 9:29. Jefferson did not respond by treating the Quran as a shared civic text. As president he refused ongoing extortion payments and fought the First Barbary War. He studied the book to understand the enemy’s reasoning. He never treated the Quran as compatible with American republican government.

Specific Conflicts with Constitutional Rights

Conservative analyses of the Quran, authentic hadith, and the major schools of Islamic law identify clear structural conflicts with the Bill of Rights and later amendments. These conflicts are documented in detail by conservative institutions such as the Heritage Foundation on Islamist ideology and American founding principles [2], the Center for Renewing America’s primer on practices in Islamic law [3], and related treatments in National Review [4]and The Federalist.[5]

These are not fringe interpretations. They reflect the mainstream historical understanding of the Quran that produced sharia as a comprehensive legal and political system.

Equality and the Fourteenth Amendment

The Constitution requires equal protection of the laws. The Quran does not. Surah 2:282 treats the testimony of two women as equal to that of one man. Surah 4:34 permits physical discipline of a rebellious wife. Some followers of Islam take this to an extreme and justify murdering a disobedient wife or daughter. Surah 4:3 allows a man up to four wives. These rules treat men and women differently under the law. That goes against the Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection.

It baffles me to see woke women in the United States embracing Islam and wearing the Burka. A personal story from a close relative who was a missionary in Africa confirms the abuse of women under Islamic law. A Muslim woman was walking down the street and Jesus appeared to her and said, “ I am Isa (the Arabic name for Jesus), follow me”. She became a Christian. When her husband found out he gathered the town men and they were going to kill her. She found out and barely escaped with her daughter and took refuge at the Bible school he was teaching at.

Free speech, free exercise, and the First Amendment

The First Amendment protects the right to criticize any religion, leave any religion, or practice none. I would not be allowed to publish this article in most Islamic countries, where blasphemy and apostasy laws criminalize criticism of Islam.

In the United Kingdom, following large-scale Muslim immigration, authorities have used public-order and communications laws to police criticism of Islam and discussion of crimes linked to some Muslim immigrants. British police have arrested citizens for social-media posts, memes, street preaching, and public comments that criticize Islam or highlight patterns in certain crimes. One report documented more than 62,000 arrests for speech-related “communications offences” over five years. [6] Documented cases include a blogger arrested at home for an anti-Hamas meme that also criticized Islam, [7] pastors detained for preaching that Islam is not a religion of peace,[8] and people prosecuted for “grossly offensive” comments about Pakistani-heritage Muslim men involved in grooming and gang rapes of girls.[9]

Classical Islamic law treats apostasy (leaving Islam) as a capital offense, grounded in prophetic tradition and supported by verses such as Quran 4:89-

”They wish you would disbelieve as they disbelieved so you would be alike. So do not take from among them allies until they emigrate for the cause of Allah. But if they turn away, then seize them and kill them wherever you find them and take not from among them any ally or helper.”

Blasphemy against the Prophet or the Quran has historically carried severe penalties. Surah 9:29 directs fighting those who do not believe until they pay the jizya (poll tax)

“Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture—[fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled.”

Blasphemy against Muhammad or the Quran is treated as a capital offense in classical Islamic jurisprudence and remains punishable by death or severe penalties in several contemporary Muslim-majority countries (Pakistan, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan under the Taliban, parts of Nigeria, etc.).

There are multiple documented cases of Muslim women and girls being killed or targeted by family members for converting to Christianity and/or marrying a Christian man. These are typically described as honor killings. Here are a few of the many cases:

United States – Texas (2012)

Jordanian immigrant Ali Mahwood-Awad Irsan was convicted and sentenced to death for murdering his daughter Nesreen’s Christian husband, Coty Beavers, and her close friend Gelareh Bagherzadeh. Prosecutors said Irsan was enraged that Nesreen left the family, converted from Islam to Christianity, and married a Christian against his wishes. His wife testified that he acted to “clean his honor.” He had also planned to kill Nesreen herself. The case was widely covered by Fox News and other outlets. [10]

Egypt (2015)

Marwa Mohamed (also reported as Marwa Ahmed), a 26-year-old Muslim woman, eloped with a Coptic Christian man, Karim Eid, converted to Christianity, and lived with him. When the couple returned to her hometown, her uncle and cousins found her, forced her younger sister to participate, and killed her in front of her parents. Egyptian and Christian media described it as an honor killing over the conversion and marriage.[11] [12]

Pakistan (around 2015)

Nadia Bibi converted to Christianity and married a Christian man, Aleem Masih. Her Muslim family tracked the couple down, abducted them, and shot them. Aleem was killed; Nadia was critically wounded. Family members later publicly claimed they had avenged the family’s shame. Human-rights monitors and Christian news outlets reported the case. [13]

Iraq (2022)

Eman Sami Maghdid (who had taken the name Maria), a 20-year-old Kurdish woman and social-media personality, was killed by her brother and uncle in Erbil. Multiple reports, including from religious-freedom groups, stated she had converted to Christianity and was preparing for baptism shortly before the murder. [14]

Other related cases

  • Rifqa Bary (Ohio/Florida, 2009): A teenage Muslim girl fled to Florida after converting to Christianity, saying her family would kill her for apostasy. Fox News and others covered her custody case extensively. She was not killed, but the case illustrated the same pattern of threatened honor violence [15]
  • Multiple additional reports from Pakistan, Somalia, and elsewhere of daughters or young women killed by relatives after converting or forming relationships with Christians.

These cases are not isolated. Honor killings of women for “dishonoring” the family by leaving Islam, dating or marrying outside the faith, or rejecting an arranged marriage are a recognized pattern in parts of the Muslim world and in some migrant communities.

These rules overturn the American principle that no religious belief or custom may be enforced by the state and that dissent, including religious dissent, is protected speech.

Cruel and unusual punishment and the Eighth Amendment

The Constitution bans cruel and unusual punishments. Traditional hudud penalties drawn from the Quran and Sunna include amputation of the hand for theft (Surah 5:38), flogging for certain sexual offenses, and, in some schools, stoning. Under American law, these punishments would clearly violate the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment.

Supremacy of the Constitution versus supremacy of divine law

Article VI of the Constitution says: “This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof… shall be the supreme Law of the Land.”

In Islamic political theory, any human-made law that conflicts with the Quran and Sunna is illegitimate. A constitution written by the people cannot override or cancel what Allah has commanded.

The U.S. Constitution contains no language stating that religious law or anything Allah has revealed can override it. It simply says the Constitution is the supreme law of the land. When an official publicly chooses the Quran for a personal oath, he is treating it as a higher authority right next to the Constitution he just swore to uphold.

Who Has Used the Quran and Who Plans To

Several Muslim officeholders have already used the Quran for their ceremonial oaths, and more plan to do so.

Keith Ellison, the first Muslim elected to Congress, used Thomas Jefferson’s own copy of the Quran for his 2007 ceremonial swearing-in. Representatives Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib have also used the Quran in their ceremonial oaths. More recently, Zohran Mamdani took his oath as mayor of New York City on a Quran. Newly elected officials are following the same path. Michigan Democrat Abdul El-Sayed, a devotee of Sharia law, who won a U.S. Senate seat, has stated publicly that he will swear on the Quran, citing Jefferson’s copy as precedent and noting other historic Qurans available in Michigan.

When an official deliberately chooses the Quran to swear on, it is not a neutral or private act. It publicly signals that this text is authoritative enough to govern their conduct when voting on bills and introducing legislation.

Given the clear conflicts already documented, this choice raises a direct problem. Their votes and the legislation they introduce can easily follow those traditional rules instead of the Constitution. That puts a book whose political teachings clash with equal rights and American self-government into the official ceremony of taking office under the very Constitution those teachings undermine.

The Oath Is a Public Commitment

Article VI requires every federal and state officer to be “bound by Oath or Affirmation, to support this Constitution.” It also forbids any religious test. The Founders understood the difference between private religious belief and public legal authority. Jefferson’s ownership of a Quran for study did not lead him to treat its rules for governing as compatible with the republic he helped create. Modern insistence that the Quran is simply another holy book for ceremonial use ignores both the text’s content and the historical experience the Founders recorded.

Because of the conflicts already noted, swearing the oath of office on the Quran means using a text whose traditional teachings on law and government contradict the Constitution in the very public ceremony of taking office under that Constitution.

An oath of office is a public commitment to the Constitution. Elevating Islam’s legal-political scripture in that moment is constitutionally incompatible. It should not be allowed. Congress, local legislatures and President Trump should stop this before January 2027.



[1] DeSantis Torches El-Sayed’s Thomas Jefferson Quran Spin with a Brutal History Lesson [WATCH]

[2] heritage.org/civil-society/report/the-challenges-islamist-ideology-americas-founding-principles,

[3] americarenewing.com/issues/primer-twenty-eight-abominable-practices-in-islamic-law,

[4] nationalreview.com/corner/ben-carson-and-islam-andrew-c-mccarthy

[5] thefederalist.com/2026/11/12/cair-lies-islam-definitely-insists-its-religion-should-control-politics

[6] breitbart.com/europe/2026/09/09/62000-people-arrested-for-speech-crimes-in-britain-over-past-five-years-report

[7] foxnews.com/world/blogger-arrested-sharing-anti-hamas-meme-online-claims-cops-know-october-7th-horrors.amp

[8] foxnews.com/media/uk-pastor-says-he-arrested-preaching-gospel-speaking-out-against-islam

[9] nationalreview.com/2025/07/the-u-k-s-double-standard-on-free-expression

[10] foxnews.com/us/jordanian-immigrant-sentenced-to-death-for-texas-honor-killings-of-son-in-law-daughters-friend

[11]christiantoday.com/article/muslim.woman.who.eloped.with.christian.man.and.embraced.jesus.killed.by.her.own.family.in.egypt.honour.killing/80584.htm;

[12] christianpost.com/news/egyptian-christian-mother-throat-slit-muslims-christian-conversion.html).

[13] christianpost.com/news/christian-man-killed-by-muslim-in-laws-after-wife-gives-her-life-to-jesus.html



[14] morningstarnews.org/2022/03/young-woman-who-left-islam-killed-in-iraq; asianews.it/en/middle-east/iraq/maria-20-killed-in-erbil-by-relatives-for-converting-to-christianity

[15] foxnews.com/story/muslim-teen-who-converted-to-christianity-says-family-threatened-to-kill-her

Tweet

Continue reading...

[ H/T The Burning Platform ]
  • Reading time 2 min read
  • Reading time 11 min read
  • Reading time 1 min read
  • Views1
  • Reading time 2 min read
  • Reading time 4 min read
  • Views1

Comments

There are no comments to display
Back
Top