Guest Post by Francis O’Neill
Milk is a liquid food expressed by an adult female mammal to feed her infant offspring. Milk alone can sustain optimum healthy life for the duration of infancy. When this period of infancy ends or the mother’s milk is unavailable people have used animal milk as a substitute, particularly that of cows.
This usage has been ongoing for thousands or years. Milk is our first food and the only food we ever live on alone. Its purpose is to keep us free of sickness and help us to thrive.
Milk and honey
The Bible refers to the promised land as “flowing with “milk and honey.” This is to suggest an idyllic land of abundance and nourishment.
Milk and honey are two substances whose sole purpose is as food. The Qu’ran refers to rivers of milk flowing in paradise and milk as being, “pure and pleasant to drink.” Raw milk and honey are two foods that do not go bad.
“Cleopatra used raw milk to enrich and whiten her skin. Hippocrates, the father of medicine, Galen, Pliny, Varro, Marcellus Empiricus, Baccius, and Anthimus prescribed raw milk for diseases. We might feel inclined to dismiss them as thoughtless quacks but those men were entrusted physicians, caring for the lives of emperors and other royalty.”
Industrialisation
During the industrial revolution many people moved from rural to urban areas and so dairies were kept on the outskirts of cities. As the cities grew, due to problems with the transportation and refrigeration of milk, cows were moved into the cities and housed in unnatural and unclean conditions. As land in cities was expensive cows were kept confined and even underground – unable to graze and eat grass.
They were often situated near breweries from which they were fed grains. These unsanitary unnatural conditions produced unhealthy milk and disease.
This nineteenth century problem received a nineteenth century solution.
Pasteurisation
Pasteurisation is the process of heating milk to kill bacteria.
Pasteurisation enabled milk produced in dirty and unhealthy conditions to be consumed. It did not return milk to a healthy natural state. Milk intended for pasteurisation is not fit to be drunk raw.When aged, pasteurised milk turns rancid and cannot be consumed.
LTLT or batch pasteurisation involves heating milk to 63C for 30 minutes (145F).
HTST or high temperature short-time involves heating milk to 72C for 15 seconds (162F).
UHT ultra high temperature involves heating milk to for 135–150°C for 1–4s (approx 275-302 °F)
These processes produce a drink filled with dead bacteria.
Louis Pasteur
Although now associated with milk, pasteurisation was initially introduced to prevent abnormal fermentation of wine and beer by Louis Pasteur (1822-95), from whom the process takes its name.
Pasteur is a controversial figure who is now considered to be a fraud:
Pasteur secreted his research, giving his family instructions to hide his notes after his death (P.85).
Homogenisation
When raw milk is allowed to sit in a bottle, the cream will rise to the top. Consumers can then recognise which milk contains the most cream and choose their suppliers accordingly. This natural process was eliminated by homogenisation, a procedure designed to prevent the separation of the cream and create milk with an even consistency.
Homogenisation involves forcing milk through narrow pipes at high pressure to smash the butter fat globules into smaller particles. It is not clear what effect the unnatural composition of these fat shards has on the body.
Standardisation
There is sometimes a discrepancy between the public’s conception of a term and its legal definition. For instance, standardisation has introduced minimum terms for the labelling of whole milk. Legally whole milk must contain at least 3.5% butterfat. Manufacturers of mass produced pasteurised milk separate the cream from the milk before controlling the addition of cream back to the skimmed milk to meet the minimum requirement of butterfat content.
Some farmers (and most in the US) add synthetic vitamin D₃ (cholecalciferol) to their pasteurised milk. Although this is an active ingredient in rat poison the dosage used in pasteurised milk is considered to be safe for consumption.
Also in the US, Vitamin A is added to most skimmed or low fat milk. Powdered skimmed milk and other additives are added to whole milk to create ‘fortified,’ milk. These products have been described as, “reconstituted milk flavoured beverages.” Processing plants also mix milk from different farms.
Raw milk is pure, natural, healthy, unprocessed, unpasteurised, unhomogenised, unadulterated milk from grass fed cows. For millennia, raw milk has been simply known as milk. Nowadays it is called raw milk because the public has been conditioned to consider pasteurised milk as the default state of milk.
Perception
When applied to milk, the word ‘raw,’ is something of a misnomer in that it suggests that there is a requirement for the raw milk to be heated or otherwise treated before consumption. ‘Pure,’ ‘natural,’ or ‘healthy,’ may be more appropriate epithets for raw milk. Raw milk is raw like a pure natural apple is raw.
Natural and Unnatural milk
Although standards of hygiene are much higher now than they were in the nineteenth century, modern industrially farmed milk involves the use of antibiotics, hormones, pesticides, larvicides, grain feed, and confined livestock, and as a result such milk is intended for pasteurisation and is not safe to be drunk raw.
Healthy, grass fed, organic, cleanly farmed cows provide milk which can be drunk raw.
Properties of raw milk
In common with honey, raw milk does not go bad.
If not refrigerated, or aged, it will become sour milk. Sour milk is safe to drink, with no loss of nutritional value. In fact as raw milk ages it becomes more probiotic and there are many benefits from the fermentation process.
“Besides having known inhibitory effects on (perceived) harmful species of bacteria (21), lactic acid (in fermented milk products) boosts the absorption of calcium, phosphorus and iron, and has been shown to make milk proteins more digestible by knocking them out of solution as fine curd particles.” Thus some people who have difficulties with milk are able to comfortably eat fermented products such as yoghurt and kefir.
Health benefits of raw milk.
In an open letter to medical practitioners the directors of the Raw Milk Institute make the following advocation for raw milk:
Source: https://www.rawmilkinstitute.org/updates/two-types-of-raw-milk
Raw milk farmer Steve Hook comments:
The Milk Cure and the Mayo Foundation
In the early 1900s in Minnesota doctors treated a variety of ailments with bed rest and a couple of gallons (there are 3.8 litres or 8 pints to a gallon) of raw milk per day, following a protocol developed by Dr. Crewe who said:
He observed that,
New Zealand doctor Ulric Williams effect cures for his patients having reached similar conclusions about raw milk and diet.
Dr JF Lyman, Prof. of Agricultural Chemistry, Ohio State University concluded that:
Dr Crewe noted that,
Raw milk Products
As milk ages the cream will separate and rise to the top and curds (solids) and whey (liquid) will form. Curds are used to make cheese.
An old nursery rhyme reads “Little miss muffet sat on a tuffet eating her curds and whey.”
This insight into rural life suggests the normality of a little miss eating a snack of aged and slightly sour milk that would be unusual for many people today.
Raw Butter
Raw butter is made by churning cream from raw milk. When the cream has been churned it separates into (solid) butter and (liquid) buttermilk. There are many benefits from raw butter.
“Butter is a rich source of easily absorbed vitamin A, needed for a wide range of functions, from maintaining good vision to keeping the endocrine system in top shape. Butter also contains all the other fat-soluble vitamins (D, E and K2), which are often lacking in the modern diet.
Minerals: butter is rich in important trace minerals, including manganese, chromium, zinc, copper and selenium (a powerful antioxidant).
Fatty Acids: butter provides appreciable amounts of short- and medium-chain fatty acids, which support immune function, boost metabolism and have anti-microbial properties; that is, they fight against pathogenic microorganisms in the intestinal tract. Butter also provides the perfect balance of omega-3 and omega-6 fats. Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA): when butter comes from cows eating green grass, it contains high levels of conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), a compound that is said to give some protection against cancer and also helps your body build muscle rather than store fat.”
There is also the,
“Wulzen Factor: a hormone-like substance that prevents arthritis and joint stiffness, ensuring that calcium in your body is put into your bones rather than your joints. The Wulzen factor is present only in (raw milk), raw butter and cream; it is destroyed by pasteurisation.”
Dr. Rosalind Wulzen of, “Wulzen Calcium Dystrophy Syndrome notoriety, reported that test animals fed pasteurized milk did not grow well and consistently developed a highly characteristic syndrome, the first sign of which was wrist stiffness, a form of arthritis.”
Raw Yoghurt
Raw milk yoghurt is made by gently heating milk below the temperature at which pasteurisation occurs (Hook and Son warm their yoghurt to 40C/104F), and then adding yoghurt culture granules. After 16-18 hours the milk has thickened into yoghurt which is then strained.
In contrast the BBC informs its viewers that yoghurt is made by mixing skimmed milk powder, sugar, and powdered milk protein, which is then heated to kill bacteria before yoghurt granules are added.
Raw Kefir
Kefir is fairly similar to yoghurt and is made by introducing kefir ‘grains’ to milk and allowing it to ferment. The kefir grains are somewhat mysterious as it is not known exactly how or where they first appeared although they are first recorded in the Caucasus mountains. The word kefir is believed to derive from the Turkish, keyif, meaning “pleasure” or “good feeling.”
Kefir has a wider variety of probiotic bacteria strains than yoghurt as well as a yeast content. Those who have problems consuming milk can often tolerate both raw yoghurt and raw kefir perhaps because most of the lactose has been consumed in the fermentation process.
Dr Eric Berg asserts that kefir contributes to, “less liver fat, less allergies, less constipation, an improved immune system, better blood sugars, (and) better blood pressure,” along with better sleep.
Raw Kefir:
Raw Colostrum
Colostrum is the first milk produced by a female mammal for her newborn infant. It is produced in the first 24 to 72 hours of lactation and is a nutrient dense formula to promote growth and health. It is slightly different from milk in its colour and function, thickness and taste. It is sometimes referred to as “liquid gold.”
There is always excess colostrum so bovine colostrum is collected from dairy cows after the calf’s needs are met, usually from the second or third milking.
Research shows that colostrum is beneficial for gut health, respiratory ailments, and athletic performance and recovery.
Raw milk as a preservative
Before the extensive use of fridges raw milk was used to preserve meat. The meat was submerged in a bath of milk. The cream in the milk would rise and form a solid barrier on the surface. Raw milk sours producing lactic acid which would effectively pickle the meat.
Lactobacillus feeds on the natural milk sugar (lactose) and converts it into lactic acid. The acidic environment and the production of natural antimicrobial compounds make it difficult for perceived dangerous bacteria or spoilage organisms to survive or multiply. This a natural protective mechanism in raw milk that was realised by people in hot countries who often preferred to drink their milk soured.
Problems with Pasteurised milk.
The process of pasteurisation kills all the bacteria, meaning that the consumer, under the impression that they are being nourished, instead drink dead bacteria. Raw milk producers are held to the highest standards of hygiene and testing and often stricter standards than pasteurized milk. Cows kept in healthy natural conditions produce less disease further negating any risk to the consumer.
Pasteurization of milk has been shown to:
Intolerance and Allergy
As with many foods there are some people who are allergic to milk, but…
Lactose intolerance
There are also some people who have an intolerance to milk, but it is also possible that these people are in fact intolerant only to pasteurised milk.
It is reported that raw milk, “facilitates the production of lactase enzyme in the intestinal tract, and thus it makes sense that so many people have reported improvements in lactose intolerance<,” by consuming raw milk.
However it is not clear how this might occur as,
Without knowing the mechanism which explains why, many people who have problems with pasteurised milk are able to consume raw milk or raw milk products. Although it is often reported to be the case, raw milk does not contain lactase.
Infant humans usually thrive on milk from their mothers. Might we expect most people to thrive when consuming milk from another mammal?
A1 and A2 cows
Cows are separated into two categories on the basis of which beta-casein protein variants they produce in their milk, but both milk types can occur within the same breed. Cows can be genetically tested to determine their type.
Breeds such as Holstein (Fresian), Ayrshire, British Shorthorn are often A1.
Jersey, Guernsey, Normande, and brown Swiss are more commonly A2.
A1 beta-casein releases a peptide called BCM-7 during digestion that has been associated with digestive discomfort,” but it has been found that both types of milk produce essentially equivalent BCM-7 levels before heat treatment, with A1 levels rising significantly after heating.
Although more research is required this means that it is possible that it is heating (pasteurisation) that causes people problems with A1 milk.
Problems attributed to raw milk
“It is important to note that there is no such thing as a perfectly safe food. An analysis of foodborne illnesses from 2009-2015 showed that the top food categories commonly linked to illnesses were chicken, pork, and seeded vegetables. Pasteurized milk is not perfectly safe, either, and is implicated in foodborne illnesses and outbreaks every year. The CDC outbreak and illness data which is used to assert that raw milk is unsafe does not distinguish raw milk intended for pasteurization from raw milk that is carefully produced and intended for direct human consumption.”
No food is completely safe, particularly if it is stored or produced in unhygienic or unsanitary conditions. There are many instances of food poisoning in foodstuffs whose reputations are not irreparably tarnished.
“Raw milk’s absolute risk figures are frequently cited in isolation. A comparison of raw milk illness data with other commonly consumed foods draws on the same CDC datasets and shows that leafy greens, oysters, and pasteurized dairy products each account for substantial illness and death within those figures.
“Of interest is the fact that there are no reports of death from fluid raw milk in the medical literature, going back over fifty years; but there have been dozens of deaths from pasteurized milk reported in the literature during the same timeframe. This is all the more remarkable considering that most of the raw milk that people drink is not regulated.”
Historically cows’ milk has been associated with tuberculosis but interestingly,
Dr Crewe successfully treated tubercolosis with raw milk.
Hippocrates told doctors hundreds of years ago that raw milk greatly alleviates tuberculosis.
Raw milk has also been associated with brucellosis which is associated with abortion but this is contested. Brucellosis has been eradicated in Britain but not in Europe. In 2017 three cases of brucellosis in New Jersey, New York and Texas were attributed to a raw milk supplier though hundreds of people drank the milk without incident. This was the only incident of brucellosis in twenty years.
In November 2017, the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture sent a letter to licensed raw milk producers in the state advising them to stop immunizing cows with the RB51 (brucellosis) vaccine -after the three cases were discovered suggesting the vaccine was implicated.
“There have been no deaths from brucellosis attributed to raw milk consumption since the eradication program succeeded in substantially eliminating the incidence of the disease and possibly even long before then.”
Dr Sam Bailey observes that the FDA and CDC make assertions about raw milk but “These agencies do not provide scientific evidence that untreated milk in itself is dangerous,” and asks, “is there any evidence that specific microbes in milk can make people sick?”
Bailey considers the possibility that chemical contamination of milk rather than bacteria may be the cause of illness but this, “doesn’t necessarily relate to the milk not being pasteurised or sterilised.”
She adds:
Can you freeze raw milk?
Although there are no specific tests of freezing raw cow’s milk evidence from freezing other types of milk points to some loss of quality.
Vonderplanitz and Campbell Douglass on Raw Milk
In 2007, Dr William Campbell Douglass, MD and Dr Aajonus Vonderplanitz produced an astonishing report in favour of raw milkthat is a scathing indictment of pasteurisation and the US authorities.
This accompanied the reprinting of their 1984 book now titled, The Raw Truth About Milk (formerly “The Milk Book”), that was subtitled “how science is destroying nature’s nearly perfect food”.
They argued that…
They found that outbreaks of disease were falsely attributed to raw milk for the benefit of big food processing business in cahoots with government. Even using what they considered to be misleading figures they found the incidences of problems caused by raw milk to be extremely rare. Even using official figures raw milk is safer than leafy greens and chicken.
Doctors Vonderplanitz and Campbell Douglass attributed an astonishing array of modern health problems to the consumption of pasteurised milk including SIDS, colic, constipation, tooth decay, juvenile diabetes, muscular dystrophy, obesity, ovarian, breast, and prostate cancer,
Equally surprising the doctors found that even “raw dirty milk was safe to drink.”
Dr. Vonderplanitz, “drank milk contaminated with bovine urine and feces milked around roaming chickens and pigs for three months,” with no ill effect.
He then worked with…
The public perception of bacteria is often that of a harmful organism, Bacteria are often described as harmful, pathogenic or parasitic, but they serve essential functions, break down waste, and change form depending on the environment. A bacteria of a given form or type in a diseased being is not evidence that the bacteria caused the disease.
Rothschilds
In 1946, Lord Nathaniel Mayer Victor Rothschild the 3rd Baron Rothschild used his maiden speech in the House of Lords to forward a motion to urge for the pasteurisation of milk. At the time 70% of milk in the UK was pasteurised.
In his speech he conflated dirty milk with raw milk and said drily (in relation to raw milk) that, “your Lordships may have something to say about the relative merits of killing off numbers of the population each year and maintaining the economic interests of a relatively small section of the community.”
He addressed the “objection often raised […] that pasteurisation takes what is called “the life” out of milk.”
This is something that pasteurisation demonstrably does, but Rothschild related it only to the loss of, “noxious bacteria,” and claiming no loss of nutritional value.
The Weston A Price Foundation contends that, “when you do an analysis for vitamins and minerals, raw milk does not look that different from pasteurized. But what is destroyed is the carrier proteins, which are destroyed by pasteurization.” Studies have shown lowered nutrient availability after pasteurisation.
In a reversal of the arguments often made for vaccines Rothschild rebuffed an argument for immunity created by raw milk by saying, “Your Lordships may agree with me that the cost of this immunity even if it existed, is somewhat high.”
In relation to this declared, ‘high cost,’ Rothschild admitted, “no precise figures are available to me on this point.” Nevertheless he went on to estimate deaths from tuberculosis at 1600 per year with casualties at 7,000 or 8,000, and associated the disease with raw milk.
Lord Middleton responded by reminding Lord Rothschild,
“of experiments by Messrs. Mattick and Golding into the nutritive properties of pasteurized milk, the results of which were published in the Lancet in 1931. I will not weary your Lordships with details, but it was conclusively proved that a diet of pasteurized milk reduced the fertility of rats by 52 per cent. Further research was described in the Lancet in 1936 when exactly the same results were confirmed.”
The 1936 study referred to by Middleton was “of baby rats. They intended to compare health of groups of the fourth generation who ate raw, pasteurized or sterilized milks. However, the litters from rats fed sterilized milk were unable to produce offspring after the first generation. The females from litters that ate pasteurized milk could not lactate by the third generation so the fourth generation died of malnutrition and starvation. All of the rats fed raw milk were healthy for all generations.”
“Dr. Francis Pottenger, MD made a 10-years study of 900 cats who were fed raw and pasteurized milks that showed little differences in the first generation but all succeeding generations of pasteurized-milk fed cats developed diseases whereas the raw-milk fed had no diseases for the all generations over 10 years.”
Lord Nathaniel Rothschild only addressed the House of Lords on one further occasion, also in 1946, that time on the subject of Palestine.
In recent years it was reported that both Queen Elizabeth II and the Queen mother insisted on raw milk.
Legal restrictions
In the UK it is illegal for raw milk to be sold through a third party meaning the customer must purchase directly from the farmer either at the farm or at markets. The sale of raw milk is illegal in Scotland.
It is heavily restricted in the US, although it is possible to obtain it in 41 states, of which 10 limit sales to the farm gate and 3 require the consumer to buy a share in a cow. For many people the state has made raw milk harder to acquire than drugs.
In response to a Department of Health Services claim that,
Vonderplanitz and Campbell-Douglass presented:
This evidence shows that raw milk provides numerous health benefits for a range of ailments. This would explain its continuous use by people for thousands of years, its advocation by physicians of various eras, and widespread positive anecdotal testimony.
In contrast the evidence presented for pasteurised milk demonstrates only harms. These findings threaten big food, big pharmaceutical and other business interests which, in turn, would explain the vilification and fear-mongering of a safe food that, “that has built-in natural safeguards (that are destroyed by pasteurization).”
In an era of increased health and whole food awareness it is strange that, if it can be demonstrated, the case is not being made for the benefits of pasteurised milk. Is it possible that such a case cannot be demonstrated? Is this why large scale modern comparative studies with raw milk are not undergone?
There is big business in ill health. The global wellness industry was estimated at $7.5million in 2025. A cheaply available universal panacea would attract powerful enemies.
Given the health benefits of raw milk and the detrimental effects attributed to pasteurised milk, imagine the loss to the pharmaceutical industrial complex if raw milk was cheaply available and widely stocked on supermarket shelves.
Steve Hook and one of his cows
Raw milk dairies that readers have recommended in the UK:
Hook and Son
Green Oaks Farms
Clifton’s Farm
Hill Farm Real Food.
Buckwell Organic
Bays Leap Organic
Find raw milk near you around the world: GetRawMilk.com
Tweet
Continue reading...
[ H/T The Burning Platform ]
What is milk?
Milk is a liquid food expressed by an adult female mammal to feed her infant offspring. Milk alone can sustain optimum healthy life for the duration of infancy. When this period of infancy ends or the mother’s milk is unavailable people have used animal milk as a substitute, particularly that of cows.
This usage has been ongoing for thousands or years. Milk is our first food and the only food we ever live on alone. Its purpose is to keep us free of sickness and help us to thrive.
Milk and honey
The Bible refers to the promised land as “flowing with “milk and honey.” This is to suggest an idyllic land of abundance and nourishment.
Milk and honey are two substances whose sole purpose is as food. The Qu’ran refers to rivers of milk flowing in paradise and milk as being, “pure and pleasant to drink.” Raw milk and honey are two foods that do not go bad.
“Cleopatra used raw milk to enrich and whiten her skin. Hippocrates, the father of medicine, Galen, Pliny, Varro, Marcellus Empiricus, Baccius, and Anthimus prescribed raw milk for diseases. We might feel inclined to dismiss them as thoughtless quacks but those men were entrusted physicians, caring for the lives of emperors and other royalty.”
Industrialisation
During the industrial revolution many people moved from rural to urban areas and so dairies were kept on the outskirts of cities. As the cities grew, due to problems with the transportation and refrigeration of milk, cows were moved into the cities and housed in unnatural and unclean conditions. As land in cities was expensive cows were kept confined and even underground – unable to graze and eat grass.
They were often situated near breweries from which they were fed grains. These unsanitary unnatural conditions produced unhealthy milk and disease.
This nineteenth century problem received a nineteenth century solution.
Pasteurisation
Pasteurisation is the process of heating milk to kill bacteria.
Pasteurisation enabled milk produced in dirty and unhealthy conditions to be consumed. It did not return milk to a healthy natural state. Milk intended for pasteurisation is not fit to be drunk raw.When aged, pasteurised milk turns rancid and cannot be consumed.
LTLT or batch pasteurisation involves heating milk to 63C for 30 minutes (145F).
HTST or high temperature short-time involves heating milk to 72C for 15 seconds (162F).
UHT ultra high temperature involves heating milk to for 135–150°C for 1–4s (approx 275-302 °F)
These processes produce a drink filled with dead bacteria.
Louis Pasteur
Although now associated with milk, pasteurisation was initially introduced to prevent abnormal fermentation of wine and beer by Louis Pasteur (1822-95), from whom the process takes its name.
Pasteur is a controversial figure who is now considered to be a fraud:
Pasteur secreted his research, giving his family instructions to hide his notes after his death (P.85).
Homogenisation
When raw milk is allowed to sit in a bottle, the cream will rise to the top. Consumers can then recognise which milk contains the most cream and choose their suppliers accordingly. This natural process was eliminated by homogenisation, a procedure designed to prevent the separation of the cream and create milk with an even consistency.
Homogenisation involves forcing milk through narrow pipes at high pressure to smash the butter fat globules into smaller particles. It is not clear what effect the unnatural composition of these fat shards has on the body.
Standardisation
There is sometimes a discrepancy between the public’s conception of a term and its legal definition. For instance, standardisation has introduced minimum terms for the labelling of whole milk. Legally whole milk must contain at least 3.5% butterfat. Manufacturers of mass produced pasteurised milk separate the cream from the milk before controlling the addition of cream back to the skimmed milk to meet the minimum requirement of butterfat content.
Some farmers (and most in the US) add synthetic vitamin D₃ (cholecalciferol) to their pasteurised milk. Although this is an active ingredient in rat poison the dosage used in pasteurised milk is considered to be safe for consumption.
Also in the US, Vitamin A is added to most skimmed or low fat milk. Powdered skimmed milk and other additives are added to whole milk to create ‘fortified,’ milk. These products have been described as, “reconstituted milk flavoured beverages.” Processing plants also mix milk from different farms.
Raw milk
Raw milk is pure, natural, healthy, unprocessed, unpasteurised, unhomogenised, unadulterated milk from grass fed cows. For millennia, raw milk has been simply known as milk. Nowadays it is called raw milk because the public has been conditioned to consider pasteurised milk as the default state of milk.
Perception
When applied to milk, the word ‘raw,’ is something of a misnomer in that it suggests that there is a requirement for the raw milk to be heated or otherwise treated before consumption. ‘Pure,’ ‘natural,’ or ‘healthy,’ may be more appropriate epithets for raw milk. Raw milk is raw like a pure natural apple is raw.
Natural and Unnatural milk
Although standards of hygiene are much higher now than they were in the nineteenth century, modern industrially farmed milk involves the use of antibiotics, hormones, pesticides, larvicides, grain feed, and confined livestock, and as a result such milk is intended for pasteurisation and is not safe to be drunk raw.
Healthy, grass fed, organic, cleanly farmed cows provide milk which can be drunk raw.
Properties of raw milk
In common with honey, raw milk does not go bad.
If not refrigerated, or aged, it will become sour milk. Sour milk is safe to drink, with no loss of nutritional value. In fact as raw milk ages it becomes more probiotic and there are many benefits from the fermentation process.
“Besides having known inhibitory effects on (perceived) harmful species of bacteria (21), lactic acid (in fermented milk products) boosts the absorption of calcium, phosphorus and iron, and has been shown to make milk proteins more digestible by knocking them out of solution as fine curd particles.” Thus some people who have difficulties with milk are able to comfortably eat fermented products such as yoghurt and kefir.
Health benefits of raw milk.
In an open letter to medical practitioners the directors of the Raw Milk Institute make the following advocation for raw milk:
Source: https://www.rawmilkinstitute.org/updates/two-types-of-raw-milk
Raw milk farmer Steve Hook comments:
The Milk Cure and the Mayo Foundation
In the early 1900s in Minnesota doctors treated a variety of ailments with bed rest and a couple of gallons (there are 3.8 litres or 8 pints to a gallon) of raw milk per day, following a protocol developed by Dr. Crewe who said:
He observed that,
New Zealand doctor Ulric Williams effect cures for his patients having reached similar conclusions about raw milk and diet.
Dr JF Lyman, Prof. of Agricultural Chemistry, Ohio State University concluded that:
Dr Crewe noted that,
Raw milk Products
As milk ages the cream will separate and rise to the top and curds (solids) and whey (liquid) will form. Curds are used to make cheese.
An old nursery rhyme reads “Little miss muffet sat on a tuffet eating her curds and whey.”
This insight into rural life suggests the normality of a little miss eating a snack of aged and slightly sour milk that would be unusual for many people today.
Raw Butter
Raw butter is made by churning cream from raw milk. When the cream has been churned it separates into (solid) butter and (liquid) buttermilk. There are many benefits from raw butter.
“Butter is a rich source of easily absorbed vitamin A, needed for a wide range of functions, from maintaining good vision to keeping the endocrine system in top shape. Butter also contains all the other fat-soluble vitamins (D, E and K2), which are often lacking in the modern diet.
Minerals: butter is rich in important trace minerals, including manganese, chromium, zinc, copper and selenium (a powerful antioxidant).
Fatty Acids: butter provides appreciable amounts of short- and medium-chain fatty acids, which support immune function, boost metabolism and have anti-microbial properties; that is, they fight against pathogenic microorganisms in the intestinal tract. Butter also provides the perfect balance of omega-3 and omega-6 fats. Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA): when butter comes from cows eating green grass, it contains high levels of conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), a compound that is said to give some protection against cancer and also helps your body build muscle rather than store fat.”
There is also the,
“Wulzen Factor: a hormone-like substance that prevents arthritis and joint stiffness, ensuring that calcium in your body is put into your bones rather than your joints. The Wulzen factor is present only in (raw milk), raw butter and cream; it is destroyed by pasteurisation.”
Dr. Rosalind Wulzen of, “Wulzen Calcium Dystrophy Syndrome notoriety, reported that test animals fed pasteurized milk did not grow well and consistently developed a highly characteristic syndrome, the first sign of which was wrist stiffness, a form of arthritis.”
Raw Yoghurt
Raw milk yoghurt is made by gently heating milk below the temperature at which pasteurisation occurs (Hook and Son warm their yoghurt to 40C/104F), and then adding yoghurt culture granules. After 16-18 hours the milk has thickened into yoghurt which is then strained.
In contrast the BBC informs its viewers that yoghurt is made by mixing skimmed milk powder, sugar, and powdered milk protein, which is then heated to kill bacteria before yoghurt granules are added.
Raw Kefir
Kefir is fairly similar to yoghurt and is made by introducing kefir ‘grains’ to milk and allowing it to ferment. The kefir grains are somewhat mysterious as it is not known exactly how or where they first appeared although they are first recorded in the Caucasus mountains. The word kefir is believed to derive from the Turkish, keyif, meaning “pleasure” or “good feeling.”
Kefir has a wider variety of probiotic bacteria strains than yoghurt as well as a yeast content. Those who have problems consuming milk can often tolerate both raw yoghurt and raw kefir perhaps because most of the lactose has been consumed in the fermentation process.
Dr Eric Berg asserts that kefir contributes to, “less liver fat, less allergies, less constipation, an improved immune system, better blood sugars, (and) better blood pressure,” along with better sleep.
Raw Kefir:
- Has over 40 strains of natural occurring bacteria.
- Naturally sweetened with fresh fruit.
- Contains over 60 live enzymes.
- Contains healthy fat soluble vitamins A, D K, E and essential B vitamins.
- Alive, active bacteria.
- A good variety of bacteria and yeast in the kefir grains used.
- Easily digested.
Raw Colostrum
Colostrum is the first milk produced by a female mammal for her newborn infant. It is produced in the first 24 to 72 hours of lactation and is a nutrient dense formula to promote growth and health. It is slightly different from milk in its colour and function, thickness and taste. It is sometimes referred to as “liquid gold.”
There is always excess colostrum so bovine colostrum is collected from dairy cows after the calf’s needs are met, usually from the second or third milking.
Research shows that colostrum is beneficial for gut health, respiratory ailments, and athletic performance and recovery.
Raw milk as a preservative
Before the extensive use of fridges raw milk was used to preserve meat. The meat was submerged in a bath of milk. The cream in the milk would rise and form a solid barrier on the surface. Raw milk sours producing lactic acid which would effectively pickle the meat.
Lactobacillus feeds on the natural milk sugar (lactose) and converts it into lactic acid. The acidic environment and the production of natural antimicrobial compounds make it difficult for perceived dangerous bacteria or spoilage organisms to survive or multiply. This a natural protective mechanism in raw milk that was realised by people in hot countries who often preferred to drink their milk soured.
Problems with Pasteurised milk.
The process of pasteurisation kills all the bacteria, meaning that the consumer, under the impression that they are being nourished, instead drink dead bacteria. Raw milk producers are held to the highest standards of hygiene and testing and often stricter standards than pasteurized milk. Cows kept in healthy natural conditions produce less disease further negating any risk to the consumer.
Pasteurization of milk has been shown to:
- Reduce the bioavailability of calcium and phosphorus
- Reduce the presence of copper and iron
- Reduce Vitamins A, B Complex, C, and E
- Destroy beta-lactoglobulin, thereby decreasing intestinal absorption of Vitamins A and D
- >Destroy probiotics, including lactobacillus and pediococcus, and
- >Inactivate beneficial enzymes, alkaline phosphatase, and lactoperoxidase.”
Intolerance and Allergy
As with many foods there are some people who are allergic to milk, but…
Lactose intolerance
There are also some people who have an intolerance to milk, but it is also possible that these people are in fact intolerant only to pasteurised milk.
It is reported that raw milk, “facilitates the production of lactase enzyme in the intestinal tract, and thus it makes sense that so many people have reported improvements in lactose intolerance<,” by consuming raw milk.
However it is not clear how this might occur as,
Without knowing the mechanism which explains why, many people who have problems with pasteurised milk are able to consume raw milk or raw milk products. Although it is often reported to be the case, raw milk does not contain lactase.
Infant humans usually thrive on milk from their mothers. Might we expect most people to thrive when consuming milk from another mammal?
A1 and A2 cows
Cows are separated into two categories on the basis of which beta-casein protein variants they produce in their milk, but both milk types can occur within the same breed. Cows can be genetically tested to determine their type.
Breeds such as Holstein (Fresian), Ayrshire, British Shorthorn are often A1.
Jersey, Guernsey, Normande, and brown Swiss are more commonly A2.
A1 beta-casein releases a peptide called BCM-7 during digestion that has been associated with digestive discomfort,” but it has been found that both types of milk produce essentially equivalent BCM-7 levels before heat treatment, with A1 levels rising significantly after heating.
Although more research is required this means that it is possible that it is heating (pasteurisation) that causes people problems with A1 milk.
Problems attributed to raw milk
“It is important to note that there is no such thing as a perfectly safe food. An analysis of foodborne illnesses from 2009-2015 showed that the top food categories commonly linked to illnesses were chicken, pork, and seeded vegetables. Pasteurized milk is not perfectly safe, either, and is implicated in foodborne illnesses and outbreaks every year. The CDC outbreak and illness data which is used to assert that raw milk is unsafe does not distinguish raw milk intended for pasteurization from raw milk that is carefully produced and intended for direct human consumption.”
No food is completely safe, particularly if it is stored or produced in unhygienic or unsanitary conditions. There are many instances of food poisoning in foodstuffs whose reputations are not irreparably tarnished.
“Raw milk’s absolute risk figures are frequently cited in isolation. A comparison of raw milk illness data with other commonly consumed foods draws on the same CDC datasets and shows that leafy greens, oysters, and pasteurized dairy products each account for substantial illness and death within those figures.
“Of interest is the fact that there are no reports of death from fluid raw milk in the medical literature, going back over fifty years; but there have been dozens of deaths from pasteurized milk reported in the literature during the same timeframe. This is all the more remarkable considering that most of the raw milk that people drink is not regulated.”
Historically cows’ milk has been associated with tuberculosis but interestingly,
Dr Crewe successfully treated tubercolosis with raw milk.
Hippocrates told doctors hundreds of years ago that raw milk greatly alleviates tuberculosis.
Raw milk has also been associated with brucellosis which is associated with abortion but this is contested. Brucellosis has been eradicated in Britain but not in Europe. In 2017 three cases of brucellosis in New Jersey, New York and Texas were attributed to a raw milk supplier though hundreds of people drank the milk without incident. This was the only incident of brucellosis in twenty years.
In November 2017, the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture sent a letter to licensed raw milk producers in the state advising them to stop immunizing cows with the RB51 (brucellosis) vaccine -after the three cases were discovered suggesting the vaccine was implicated.
“There have been no deaths from brucellosis attributed to raw milk consumption since the eradication program succeeded in substantially eliminating the incidence of the disease and possibly even long before then.”
Dr Sam Bailey observes that the FDA and CDC make assertions about raw milk but “These agencies do not provide scientific evidence that untreated milk in itself is dangerous,” and asks, “is there any evidence that specific microbes in milk can make people sick?”
Bailey considers the possibility that chemical contamination of milk rather than bacteria may be the cause of illness but this, “doesn’t necessarily relate to the milk not being pasteurised or sterilised.”
She adds:
Can you freeze raw milk?
Although there are no specific tests of freezing raw cow’s milk evidence from freezing other types of milk points to some loss of quality.
Vonderplanitz and Campbell Douglass on Raw Milk
In 2007, Dr William Campbell Douglass, MD and Dr Aajonus Vonderplanitz produced an astonishing report in favour of raw milkthat is a scathing indictment of pasteurisation and the US authorities.
This accompanied the reprinting of their 1984 book now titled, The Raw Truth About Milk (formerly “The Milk Book”), that was subtitled “how science is destroying nature’s nearly perfect food”.
They argued that…
They found that outbreaks of disease were falsely attributed to raw milk for the benefit of big food processing business in cahoots with government. Even using what they considered to be misleading figures they found the incidences of problems caused by raw milk to be extremely rare. Even using official figures raw milk is safer than leafy greens and chicken.
Doctors Vonderplanitz and Campbell Douglass attributed an astonishing array of modern health problems to the consumption of pasteurised milk including SIDS, colic, constipation, tooth decay, juvenile diabetes, muscular dystrophy, obesity, ovarian, breast, and prostate cancer,
Equally surprising the doctors found that even “raw dirty milk was safe to drink.”
Dr. Vonderplanitz, “drank milk contaminated with bovine urine and feces milked around roaming chickens and pigs for three months,” with no ill effect.
He then worked with…
The public perception of bacteria is often that of a harmful organism, Bacteria are often described as harmful, pathogenic or parasitic, but they serve essential functions, break down waste, and change form depending on the environment. A bacteria of a given form or type in a diseased being is not evidence that the bacteria caused the disease.
Rothschilds
In 1946, Lord Nathaniel Mayer Victor Rothschild the 3rd Baron Rothschild used his maiden speech in the House of Lords to forward a motion to urge for the pasteurisation of milk. At the time 70% of milk in the UK was pasteurised.
In his speech he conflated dirty milk with raw milk and said drily (in relation to raw milk) that, “your Lordships may have something to say about the relative merits of killing off numbers of the population each year and maintaining the economic interests of a relatively small section of the community.”
He addressed the “objection often raised […] that pasteurisation takes what is called “the life” out of milk.”
This is something that pasteurisation demonstrably does, but Rothschild related it only to the loss of, “noxious bacteria,” and claiming no loss of nutritional value.
The Weston A Price Foundation contends that, “when you do an analysis for vitamins and minerals, raw milk does not look that different from pasteurized. But what is destroyed is the carrier proteins, which are destroyed by pasteurization.” Studies have shown lowered nutrient availability after pasteurisation.
In a reversal of the arguments often made for vaccines Rothschild rebuffed an argument for immunity created by raw milk by saying, “Your Lordships may agree with me that the cost of this immunity even if it existed, is somewhat high.”
In relation to this declared, ‘high cost,’ Rothschild admitted, “no precise figures are available to me on this point.” Nevertheless he went on to estimate deaths from tuberculosis at 1600 per year with casualties at 7,000 or 8,000, and associated the disease with raw milk.
Lord Middleton responded by reminding Lord Rothschild,
“of experiments by Messrs. Mattick and Golding into the nutritive properties of pasteurized milk, the results of which were published in the Lancet in 1931. I will not weary your Lordships with details, but it was conclusively proved that a diet of pasteurized milk reduced the fertility of rats by 52 per cent. Further research was described in the Lancet in 1936 when exactly the same results were confirmed.”
The 1936 study referred to by Middleton was “of baby rats. They intended to compare health of groups of the fourth generation who ate raw, pasteurized or sterilized milks. However, the litters from rats fed sterilized milk were unable to produce offspring after the first generation. The females from litters that ate pasteurized milk could not lactate by the third generation so the fourth generation died of malnutrition and starvation. All of the rats fed raw milk were healthy for all generations.”
“Dr. Francis Pottenger, MD made a 10-years study of 900 cats who were fed raw and pasteurized milks that showed little differences in the first generation but all succeeding generations of pasteurized-milk fed cats developed diseases whereas the raw-milk fed had no diseases for the all generations over 10 years.”
Lord Nathaniel Rothschild only addressed the House of Lords on one further occasion, also in 1946, that time on the subject of Palestine.
In recent years it was reported that both Queen Elizabeth II and the Queen mother insisted on raw milk.
Legal restrictions
In the UK it is illegal for raw milk to be sold through a third party meaning the customer must purchase directly from the farmer either at the farm or at markets. The sale of raw milk is illegal in Scotland.
It is heavily restricted in the US, although it is possible to obtain it in 41 states, of which 10 limit sales to the farm gate and 3 require the consumer to buy a share in a cow. For many people the state has made raw milk harder to acquire than drugs.
Conclusion
In response to a Department of Health Services claim that,
Vonderplanitz and Campbell-Douglass presented:
This evidence shows that raw milk provides numerous health benefits for a range of ailments. This would explain its continuous use by people for thousands of years, its advocation by physicians of various eras, and widespread positive anecdotal testimony.
In contrast the evidence presented for pasteurised milk demonstrates only harms. These findings threaten big food, big pharmaceutical and other business interests which, in turn, would explain the vilification and fear-mongering of a safe food that, “that has built-in natural safeguards (that are destroyed by pasteurization).”
In an era of increased health and whole food awareness it is strange that, if it can be demonstrated, the case is not being made for the benefits of pasteurised milk. Is it possible that such a case cannot be demonstrated? Is this why large scale modern comparative studies with raw milk are not undergone?
There is big business in ill health. The global wellness industry was estimated at $7.5million in 2025. A cheaply available universal panacea would attract powerful enemies.
Given the health benefits of raw milk and the detrimental effects attributed to pasteurised milk, imagine the loss to the pharmaceutical industrial complex if raw milk was cheaply available and widely stocked on supermarket shelves.
Steve Hook and one of his cows
Raw milk dairies that readers have recommended in the UK:
Hook and Son
Green Oaks Farms
Clifton’s Farm
Hill Farm Real Food.
Buckwell Organic
Bays Leap Organic
Find raw milk near you around the world: GetRawMilk.com
Tweet
Continue reading...
[ H/T The Burning Platform ]