Missouri officials urged a federal appeals court on Tuesday to revive their lawsuit over diversity, equity, and inclusion policies at Starbucks, which they say unlawfully discriminated against white people.
A three-judge panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit heard arguments over whether to reverse a federal district court’s February ruling tossing the lawsuit for being too broad. Missouri Solicitor General Louis Capozzi argued that allowing the district court’s ruling to stand would “cripple” the state’s ability to bring racial discrimination lawsuits in the future. Capozzi also rejected the lower court’s finding that the state did not outline a claim, arguing that it has alleged a pattern of people being denied promotions, benefits, or jobs on the basis of their race.
Missouri’s lawsuit targeted Starbucks’s policies setting quotas for hiring black people, indigenous people, and people of color, allegedly tying bonuses to those goals, along with creating a mentorship program that was only open to racial minorities. The Show-Me State alleges the policies are unlawfully discriminatory against white people.
The panel of judges questioned Capozzi over the factual allegations against Starbucks, specifically who has alleged discrimination against the company and why their allegations are not detailed. Capozzi noted that more than four dozen people had alleged they were denied jobs or benefits on the basis of their race.
The lawsuit was filed by then-Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey in February 2025. Bailey left the position later that year to take a job in the Department of Justice. Bailey’s successor, Missouri Attorney General Catherine Hanaway, continued the lawsuit and appealed the adverse ruling in district court, even after Bailey left.
Capozzi was questioned by one of the judges if there were complaints about Starbucks’s DEI policies filed to the attorney general’s office or if “the attorney general [was] just looking around for a company to target and say, ‘you’re ‘woke’ or DEI and we’re going to take you to court.'” Capozzi responded that he was unsure but defended the lawsuit by noting that because racial quotas are facially discriminatory, the state’s lawsuit against Starbucks should proceed.
James Bennett, representing Starbucks, argued to the panel that Missouri’s lawsuit lacked a basis and was not tied to specific allegations. Bennett’s claims were met with pushback by the panel, which questioned if it was too early in the lawsuit to know if the state had firm examples of discrimination it planned to introduce later in the course of the lawsuit. The panel appeared generally skeptical of the coffee giant’s bid to uphold the lower court’s ruling.
APPEALS COURT GRAPPLES WITH COLORADO ANTIDISCRIMINATION LAW REQUIRING PREFERRED PRONOUNS
The three-judge panel included U.S. Circuit Judges L. Steven Grasz, Ralph Erickson, and Daniel Traynor, all three appointees of President Donald Trump. The Eighth Circuit panel did not indicate how or when it would rule.
DEI has been a target of the DOJ under the Trump administration, along with Republican-led state attorney general offices across the country. Trump has signed executive orders stripping DEI initiatives from the federal government, alleging the programs are discriminatory, and the DOJ has filed lawsuits seeking to end DEI in multiple companies.
Continue reading...
[ H/T Washington Examiner ]