By eliminating the New York Police Department’s Strategic Response Group policing unit, Mayor Zohran Mamdani has underlined that his fealty is to far-left ideologues rather than to New York City residents.
The SRG was established in 2015 so police could respond effectively to terrorist attacks, violent protests, and civil unrest. This put the SRG at odds with those who want to occupy buildings, threaten other city residents, and in other ways break the law. In 2024, the SRG cleared violent demonstrators, including students and outsiders, who took over buildings at Columbia University. Its effectiveness made it a magnet for leftist fury. The antis complained repeatedly that the SRG was using excessive force, but very few such allegations were upheld on civilian review. Campaigning for mayor, Mamdani boosted his far-left credentials by pledging to scrap the SRG.
It would be acceptable if Mamdani’s plan meant returning the SRG’s counterterrorism responsibilities to the NYPD’s Counterterrorism Bureau or replacing the SRG with another separate organization. But Mamdani has scrapped the SRG without replacing its necessary capabilities.
His alternate strategy is farcical. His new protest policing will center on deploying unarmed civilians attached to a new “Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division” within his own office. This sounds like a joke, but it isn’t. It is an extension of the thinking that led Democrats to replace police officers with de-escalation teams in 2020/2021. These were predictably disastrous, leading to increased crime rates because criminals knew impunity when they saw it.
Mamdani recognizes that he must provide at least token policing capability in the SRG’s place. So, the NYPD will now deploy a 30-officer “First Amendment Support Team” trained in de-escalation tactics. Such a puny force will not be able to handle a protest numbering in the thousands. No worries. Mamdani has another trick up his sleeve. The First Amendment team will be supported by a new Patrol Support Division under the supervision of the Patrol Services Bureau.
Mamdani is no fool, but he seems to believe his constituents are fools. For there are two glaring problems with his new approach, and people will notice.
First, the officers replacing the SRG will lack the training and resources to handle serious disorder. The Patrol Services Bureau is responsible for street-level law enforcement, not protests or riot control operations. Mamdani’s reforms therefore risk protests spiraling out of control, for he is replacing officers specifically trained for protests with others with no relevant training and experience.
He is also tying the hands of these inexperienced officers. Tasked with protecting citizens, businesses, and counterprotesters often threatened by disorderly protests, officers will be banned from using tear gas and other riot control equipment. Even more absurd, they won’t be allowed to use so-called “kettling” tactics. Kettling is a prerequisite for restoring calm amid disorder because it allows officers to box in or otherwise control the movement of crowds so their ringleaders can be detained and massed groups cannot run riot across the city (evading the police).
Mamdani’s approach is the opposite of that adopted by major metropolitan police forces around the world. Take the Civil Disturbance Unit and Special Events Branch of the Washington, D.C., police. Or the Royal Canadian Mounted Police’s Tactical Support Group? Or London’s Metropolitan Police Territorial Support Group? Or France’s CRS units, the BFE in Germany, and the Italian police’s Mobile Units?
COLOMBIA’S NEW PRESIDENT BRINGS COUNTRY BACK INTO TRUMP’S ORBIT, WITH SOME DIFFICULTIES
Such units reflect an understanding that dealing with dynamic protests is complicated work that requires specialized units trained to address protests, whether they be peaceful or riotous. Police officers put on the front line of a protest need to adapt to rapidly changing circumstances and must remain calm amid high stress and relentless efforts by protesters to provoke them.
Sadly, as Mamdani cares more about far-left virtue signaling than he does about the protection of city residents, their property, and the rule of law, New York City is soon to be more vulnerable.
Continue reading...
[ H/T Washington Examiner ]