The law that affected the outcome of Murray’s immigration case is not new.
It is 86 years old.
The law is the Nationality Act of 1940. President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed it Oct. 14, 1940. It was effective Jan. 13, 1941, and remained in effect in 1951, when Murray was born in Canada. He moved with his family to Erie in 1956.
The Nationality Act codified laws related to naturalization and birthright citizenship. One part of the law applied to children born abroad when one parent was a U.S. citizen and the other parent was not.
That was the part of the law that applied to Murray’s case.
The law required the American parent to have 10 years of residence in the United States or an outlying possession before the child’s birth.
Murray, 75, told the Erie Times-News that he had always considered himself a U.S. citizen because he understood that his mother, who was born in Canada, was a dual U.S.-Canadian citizen when he was born.
Murray came to a different realization when he applied for a U.S. passport about a year and a half ago, the first time he had ever done so.
Murray said his passport application ultimately prompted a review of his mother’s U.S. residence history, which led to the determination that he did not acquire U.S. citizenship at birth.
Murray’s mother, Dorothea Murray, left Canada for Erie in 1939 and was in the United States until 1949, when her family returned to Canada. The family returned to Erie permanently in 1956.
Between her move to Erie in 1939 and Ian Murray’s birth in 1951, Dorothea Murray spent four years attending the University of Toronto. Ian Murray said those four years were key to the determination that he was not a U.S. citizen.
He said the semesters his mother spent at the University of Toronto did not count under the Nationality Act of 1940. The time his mother spent in the United States during the summer and on holiday breaks did count, he said.
Murray said excluding those semesters left his mother just shy of meeting the 10-year residence requirement, meaning that he did not acquire U.S. citizenship at birth.