Lindsay Clancy is headed back to court for a second murder trial on March 29, 2027, after a Massachusetts judge rejected prosecutors’ request to wait until May.
The former nurse faces three first-degree murder charges in the strangling deaths of her young children. Her first trial ended Sept. 4 with a jury split 11-1, with only one juror favoring a murder conviction.
The other 11 supported finding Clancy not criminally responsible because of mental illness.
Judge William Sullivan pushed both sides to settle on a March or April date before choosing March 29 for the retrial in Plymouth Superior Court.
“You’ve all done retrials, and generally, the sooner it is the case is retried, the better it is for all parties,” he said.
Assistant Plymouth County District Attorney Jennifer Sprague sought a May start, citing other cases already scheduled for trial. Prosecutors later pushed for late April, but Sullivan chose the earlier date.
The ruling came a week after Sullivan rejected a defense bid to block another trial on double jeopardy grounds.
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington said he expects prosecutors to pursue the same first-degree murder counts, although they did not explicitly announce their charging plans.
Reddington has urged Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz to reconsider the case. He told Fox News’ Bryan Llenas in September that reducing the charges to second-degree murder could allow the defense to seek a trial before a judge instead of another jury.
“I would like to see [Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz] reduce it to a second-degree so we could possibly waive a jury and try the case before a judge,” he said. “I would see Tim determine that the case should not go forward and dismiss it, or in the alternative fashion, something where Lindsay gets the mental, physical help that she needs rather than criminal prosecution — because I would not ever, ever in a million years have that woman go to Framingham State Prison.”
Clancy’s defense does not dispute that she killed the children. The central fight is whether her mental illness left her criminally responsible. Prosecutors maintain she planned the killings and understood her actions.
On Jan. 24, 2023, Patrick Clancy returned from running errands to find his then-wife critically injured in the backyard of their Duxbury home and their three children strangled inside.
Cora, 5, and Dawson, 3, were pronounced dead at a hospital that night. Their brother, Callan, 8 months, died three days later at Boston Children’s Hospital.
Prosecutors said Lindsay Clancy attempted suicide after attacking the children. Her injuries left her paralyzed, and she has remained in custody at a Massachusetts hospital.
Sullivan’s approaching retirement adds another complication to the retrial schedule. A delay could put a different judge in charge of the case.
Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge and law professor, said a bench trial would consume significantly fewer resources than a second jury trial. He also questioned whether the March start date would hold.
“Perhaps this will be the unusual murder trial that goes off without a hitch,” he told Fox News Digital. “For example, have the attorneys double-checked and locked in the availability of experts? This could delay the trial.”
Lu also challenged giving Clancy’s retrial priority over other pending murder cases.
“My answer: It should not,” he said Monday.
“It appears to be pushing aside older murder trials,” Lu said. “I agree with the prosecutor on this point: ‘It is unfair to them.’ Them is victims and defendants in other murder cases.”
POLL: Will America Regret Giving The Democrats Power?
Continue reading...
[ H/T Trending Politics ]