JD Vance and the debate over victory in Iran

AP26317024240722.jpg


JD VANCE AND THE DEBATE OVER VICTORY IN IRAN. Vice President JD Vance famously disagreed with President Donald Trump’s decision to start the war against Iran. Vance was one of the skeptics — there were several — after Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visited the White House in February and sought to persuade Trump and top U.S. officials to initiate strikes not only to knock out Iran’s nuclear weapons program but also to bring about regime change. According to published reports, top officials such as Secretary of State Marco Rubio and CIA Director John Ratcliffe characterized Netanyahu’s pitch as “bulls***” and “farcical.” As for the vice president, Vance reportedly “believed a regime-change war with Iran would be a disaster.” Nevertheless, when Trump decided to attack on Feb. 28, Vance stood up, saluted, and publicly supported the move.

Still, everyone knew Vance did not believe the war was a good idea. And then he ended up bungling the peace talks that led to the ultimately meaningless Memorandum of Understanding between the U.S. and Iran. In those talks, Vance placed too much faith in the Iranians’ hoped-for willingness to negotiate seriously. It turned out there was no such willingness, and there have not been serious negotiations since.

In the big picture, though, there is no question that the U.S. has achieved the war’s main goal, which was ensuring that Iran cannot obtain a nuclear weapon. Starting with the American bombing raid of June 2025 and continuing with the current war that began in February 2026, American forces have pounded every component of Iran’s nuclear weapons program. It will take a long time for Iran to recover.

How long is not clear. At various times since the 2025 strike, Trump has said it would take Iran “a couple of years” or “years” or “25 years” or “basically decades” to rebuild its nuclear weapons program. Other senior U.S. officials have said American strikes have done serious damage to Iranian capabilities.

Speaking at Naval Air Station Oceana in Virginia in July, Vance said, “If you look at what our own intelligence says about their nuclear program, they are farther away from developing a nuclear bomb than they have ever been since basically the last 20 or 30 years.” Early this month, Vance said, “Having destroyed their nuclear program, we want to make sure they don’t rebuild or try to rebuild it.”

There seems no doubt that Vance agrees that Iran should not have a nuclear weapon. If more evidence is needed, here are a few examples of him saying so:

  • In July 2024, during the presidential campaign, Vance said, “I think war often leads to unintended consequences, but preventing Iran from getting a bomb — really, really important.” Referring to Trump’s penchant for quick, forceful attacks, like taking out Iranian Quds Force leader Qasem Soleimani, Vance said, “If you’re going to punch the Iranians, you punch them hard.”
  • In June 2025, shortly before the U.S. bombing of Iranian nuclear facilities, Vance said, “POTUS has been amazingly consistent, over ten years, that Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon … the president has made clear that Iran cannot have uranium enrichment.”
  • In June 2025, immediately after the bombing, Vance said, “We do not want war with Iran. We actually want peace, but we want peace in the context of them not having a nuclear weapons program.”
  • In June 2025, also shortly after the bombing, Vance said, “Iran was very close to having a nuclear weapon … now Iran is incapable of building a nuclear weapon with the equipment they have, because we destroyed it … President Trump has obliterated the Iranian nuclear program.”
  • In February 2026, before the start of the war, Vance said, “The president has told his entire senior team that we should be trying to cut a deal that ensures the Iranians don’t have nuclear weapons. But if we can’t cut that deal, then there’s another option on the table.”
  • Also in February, Vance said, “The president has been as crystal clear as he could be: Iran can’t have a nuclear weapon … I think most Americans understand that you can’t let the craziest and worst regime in the world have nuclear weapons.”
  • On May 19, 2026, in the third month of the war, Vance said, “Loud and clear since day one: Iran can NEVER have a nuclear weapon.”

There are more such examples. A June 2025 article in Politico noted Vance’s support in light of his previously stated opposition to a wider war in the Middle East. “The vibe shift from [Vance] is notable, and it underscores the political currency that the president has built up within his own party,” Politico reported. “A longtime isolationist who served with the Marines in Iraq, Vance previously opposed any proactive military intervention against Iran in its own territory. But last week, he responded to debate around Trump’s political authority and decision-making with an impassioned post on social media, arguing: ‘The president has earned some trust on this issue.’”

In that post, Vance also said, “I have yet to see a single good argument for why Iran needed to enrich uranium well above the threshold for civilian use. I’ve yet to see a single good argument for why Iran was justified in violating its non-proliferation obligations. I’ve yet to see a single good pushback against the IAEA’s findings.”

There seems to be little doubt that, certainly by the time of the 2025 strike on the Iranian nuclear facilities, Vance supported what would become the primary goal of the war — to ensure that Iran does not obtain a nuclear weapon. But eight months later, he did not buy Netanyahu’s pitch for regime change — remember the reporting that Vance “believed a regime-change war with Iran would be a disaster.”

It doesn’t seem that complicated — a top American official believed Iran should not be allowed to have a nuclear weapon and supported U.S. military action to ensure that, but at the same time did not support a U.S. military attempt to force regime change in Iran. Vance likely has many allies in his view, both in the government and out.

Yet in recent months, there has been a tendency among some of the war’s most fervent supporters to conflate the two goals, arguing that regime change is necessary to ensure that Iran never, ever, ever develops a nuclear weapon, and therefore anything short of a resumption of major combat operations to topple the regime falls short of the war’s purpose. For them, Vance has emerged as a bad guy in the war effort.

Then came the midterm elections. By supporting the move to make sure Iran does not obtain a nuclear weapon, even as he opposed regime change, Vance was still probably to the right of the majority of voters in the recent midterm elections; most of them opposed the war. But then there was the election analysis Vance posted on X the morning after the midterms.

“The reason we lost is the war,” Vance wrote. “The president himself said so last night.”

That brief statement set off a firestorm among the war’s most ardent supporters. Some argued that voters who cited the war as a crucial or major factor in their decision were in fact frustrated with Trump for stopping short of total victory; they voted for Democrats because they wanted more war. That was, in short, a nonsensical position.

But Vance did overstate the large part the war played in the vote. According to exit polls, the top three issues that voters described as crucial or major factors in their vote were (1) “government corruption,” which was named by 90% of the voters, and which Democrats won with 56%; (2) “cost of living,” which was named by 89% of the voters, which Democrats won with 58%; and (3) the Iran war, which was named by 74% of the voters, which Democrats won with 63%.

So there was no single reason for as massive a defeat as happened on Nov. 3. Plus, some of the reasons overlapped, especially the cost of living and the war. Many voters correctly blamed the war for the increase in gas and diesel prices over the last several months. With that in mind, it’s probably fair to say that the war accounted for one and a half of the top three reasons voters cited as crucial or major factors for their votes.

In addition, a well-known Democratic data analyst, David Shor, pointed out that the war seemed to crash Trump’s job approval rating, which was a key factor in midterm voting. The president’s job approval had been pretty steady in the 40s for a long time, Shor wrote, “But then, the Iran war happened. And there was a giant structural shift in public opinion. His approval rating on the cost of living plummeted. To put some numbers on this, the day before the Iran war, Donald Trump had a 49% approval rating on gas prices. Within a week, it was 33%.”

Remember that presidents almost always lose seats in midterm elections. It would have been very unusual had Trump not lost seats. But if Shor is correct, it seems fair to say that while Trump was always going to lose the midterms, he would have done so in a way that presidents usually lose midterms. Then the war elevated a run-of-the-mill loss into a historic defeat.

So Vance went too far. Perhaps a more accurate way to state his argument would have been that the overall reason Republicans lost was that presidents normally lose midterms, but the reason Republicans lost in such a history-making blowout was … the war. Still, in retrospect, there was no reason for Vance to post such an extensive commentary on the morning after the defeat, when the voters’ reasons were just becoming clear. If Vance had taken more time to think about things, he might have expressed himself differently.

On the other hand, none of that changes the basic fact that the vice president has vocally supported the main goal of the war — to ensure that Iran does not obtain a nuclear weapon. Nor does it change the fact that that goal has been achieved.

Vance’s position received some additional support recently from Secretary of State Marco Rubio, in a Nov. 13 speech to the Federalist Society. An audience member asked Rubio: “What would you consider an American victory?” Rubio noted that “frankly, the economic pain that we are inflicting on that regime is so great that there’s no need for military action, because we’ve weakened them so much.” And then: “I think victory is ensuring that they never have a nuclear weapon.”

Rubio did not define victory as deposing the current Iranian regime. He did not suggest any other measure of U.S. triumph. He said victory was ensuring that Iran can never have a nuclear weapon.

Did Rubio’s use of the word “never” indicate that he favors the U.S. forcing regime change on the grounds that Iran “never” having a nuclear weapon would require a new regime? Well, on other occasions, Rubio has said the same thing but without “never,” as in his statement from last month that “Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon, simple, period, and end of story,” and his statement from the first few months of the war in which he said, “Iran is not going to have a nuclear weapon.”

That, of course, was quite similar to what the vice president has said many times. Now Vance’s morning-after statement on the causes of the GOP loss has set off a debate over what victory in Iran means, and maybe that’s not a bad thing.

Continue reading...

[ H/T Washington Examiner ]

Comments

There are no comments to display
Back
Top