Summary
- On Nov. 3, 2026, Texas voters elected Democrat Gina Hinojosa governor and James Talarico to the U.S. Senate.
- Democrats also won control of the Texas House, while Republicans retained a majority in the state Senate.
- The election raises questions about the durability of Texas corporate-governance policies as federal shareholder-proposal rules face possible rescission.
Justice Louis Brandeis praised the states as laboratories, but he never promised that the experiments would confirm the hypothesis.
On Nov. 3, Texas voters ran an experiment that may unsettle a hypothesis on which much of corporate America has lately wagered.
Since 1942, when the Securities and Exchange Commission adopted the predecessor of Rule 14a-8, Washington has dictated which shareholder proposals a public company must include in its proxy materials. Those proposals can be a valuable channel through which owners, The Heritage Foundation among them, hold boards to account.
But in September, the commission proposed rescinding the rule, reasoning that the Securities Exchange Act authorizes regulation of proxy disclosure, not the substance of corporate governance, which has always been the business of the states that charter corporations.
Rescission, then, would not abolish but “repatriate” shareholder engagement. Who may submit proposals for shareholder consideration, what ownership thresholds apply, and whether companies must include those proposals in their proxy materials would increasingly become questions of state law and corporate governing documents. Federal rules governing proxy solicitation, however, would remain.
Eight decades of federal occupation of the proxy process, however, left the states with less room to experiment. Federal law, like a great oak, starves what tries to grow beneath it. Heritage supports rescission but has urged a two-year grace period (see here, here, and here), so legislatures, several of which meet only biennially, can build the scaffolding Washington proposes to remove.
No state matters more to this effort than Texas. It’s become the destination of choice for companies weary of Delaware’s capricious chancery court and other states’ hostility. Tesla and SpaceX decamped in 2024. Coinbase followed in 2025. This year Dell announced its departure from Delaware, and ExxonMobil, incorporated in New Jersey since 1882, when Chester Arthur was president, completed its move to the state where it has long been headquartered (see here and here).
Texas, more than other states, has been preparing for these arrivals. A 2025 amendment to its Business Organizations Code, now codified at Section 21.373, allows qualifying nationally listed corporations with a principal office in Texas, or listed on a qualifying Texas-based exchange, to opt into a shareholder-proposal regime through their governing documents. Under that law, a proponent must hold the lesser of $1 million in voting shares or 3% of the voting shares for at least six months, maintain that ownership through the shareholder meeting, and solicit holders representing at least 67% of the voting power.
The aim was to deter frivolous proposals, but the effect may be to concentrate voice. A retiree with a modest stake cannot clear a $1 million bar. BlackRock, Vanguard, State Street, and CalPERS clear it without difficulty. Small holders may band together. Herding thousands of strangers, however, costs far more than a phone call among a few giants.
A rule meant to discipline activism could thus leave the field to the largest activists, institutions that vote other people’s money while too often pursuing their own agendas. Shareholder democracy reserved for the biggest shareholders seems curious indeed. Still, Texas offered the most developed answer to the question that rescission poses.
Then came Nov. 3. Democrats, who had not won a statewide election in Texas since 1994, won every statewide executive office on the ballot. Gina Hinojosa defeated Gov. Greg Abbott with about 53% of the vote. James Talarico defeated Ken Paxton for the U.S. Senate. Democrats flipped the state House for the first time in more than two decades, while Republicans retained their majority in the state Senate, now presided over by a Democrat lieutenant governor.
Will companies keep coming? Perhaps not, for several reasons.
First, Texas’ appeal was never merely its statutes but the assurance that they would endure. Capital, like Burke’s society, prizes prescription, and the election introduces what corporate lawyers price most dearly: uncertainty.
Second, the governor appoints the business court’s judges, subject to Senate confirmation. Abbott has already reappointed all 10 judges through September 2028, but future vacancies and appointments will eventually put the institution in the hands of an administration that owes nothing to its designers.
“DExit” was accelerated, in part, by controversial Delaware Chancery Court decisions, especially the ruling voiding Elon Musk’s Tesla compensation package, which fueled concerns that an increasingly interventionist judiciary could override boards and shareholders in major corporate-governance disputes. Although the court’s reasoning was considerably more complex than “Musk makes too much money,” the episode shows why a materially more activist or plaintiff-friendly judiciary could change the legal-risk calculus for corporations.
Third, the attorney general’s office will belong to a Democrat who has already threatened to abandon several of his predecessor’s corporate lawsuits, including cases involving BlackRock and State Street.
Fourth, Hinojosa campaigned for a moratorium on new data centers and, in 2021, collaborated with House Democrats on a Texas Climate Plan targeting emissions reductions, including those associated with the oil and gas industry. That is unwelcome news for ExxonMobil.
Finally, a Legislature that convenes in January with a Democrat House could revisit SB 1057 itself, though a Republican-controlled Senate remains a substantial obstacle.
None of this is fatal. Texas still has abundant land and an economy built on fundamentals rather than on the fortunes of one party. And it has no personal income tax! Reincorporation is expensive and not lightly reversed. But Nevada, and a chastened Delaware, are no doubt paying attention.
Which brings us to the larger lesson. The 14a-8 debate is not about whether shareholders should engage; they should and will. It’s about who writes the rules. Federalism means that a company’s state of incorporation is no longer a formality delegated to junior associates but a strategic wager on a state’s entire legal culture.
Rescission will make that wager weightier. Texas reminds us that the bet is placed not on a statute but on a polity, and polities, as Texans just demonstrated, may change their minds. What one legislature writes, the next may unwrite; sound corporate law must be built to outlast any single election.
Continue reading...
[ H/T The Daily Signal ]