Guest Post by Hardscrabble Farmer
The past couple of weeks I’ve been helping a friend two towns over with a little carpentry. The route takes me through one of the larger towns in our region and as I was waiting for a light at my last turn I looked up on the embankment and noticed a robot lawn mower. I’ve never seen one before, but it was pretty obvious what it was and I was able to find it easily online to check out the specs.
Amazon.com: Mammotion LUBA 2 AWD 5000HX Robot Lawn Mower with 4G, Reception 1.25 Acres, Max. 1.48 Acres, All-Wheel-Drive for 80% Slope, UltraSense AI Vision & RTK Automatic Edge Mapping, 2.2″-4.0″ Cutting Height : Patio, Lawn & Garden
The mower was stalled on the slope and you could clearly see where it had been trying to get traction by all the soil that had been churned up around it. It wasn’t moving and based on my casual observation it wasn’t moving anytime soon. The grade on that slope was 20 degrees, easy and it wasn’t the sort of hillside you’d want to mow on foot unless you were very young and athletic. There wasn’t actually much in the way of grass growing there anyway, a mix of switchgrass and little bluestem mixed with some other common weeds from the sidewalk at the bottom to the parking lot at top of the hill. I decided to circle back around so I could take a photo of it to show anyone who wanted to see it the next time I went on one of my Kaczynski rants. By the time I got back to that intersection I noticed that the robot had an operator, a guy in khaki pants with one of those key chains attached to his belt loop that indicated some sort of maintenance role for the nursing home beyond the parking lot. He was holding a controller looking somewhat perplexed while the robot twitched and stalled in place. I was at a red lights, o I took my photo and then, on impulse I called out to the guy working the controls-
Robot fail!
He looked at me with a dour expression and replied, I like it. And then the light turned green and I pulled out into traffic. By the time I circled back the second time and drove past, I looked up and noticed that the robot still hadn’t moved.
I finished my work that afternoon around 4:30 and headed home, beat and sore from my work but glad to have been of help. When I got to the intersection where I’d seen the robot earlier, I had completely forgotten about it. There were a few more patches of churned up dirt where it had apparently run into the same stalling troubles it had experienced earlier, and there were several large patches where it had clearly not been able to mow at all, but it was gone and so was the operator.
As I have written so many times in the past, I don’t believe in robots. Not that they exist, at least in the Ford assembly plant/Roomba vacuum level, but as fully autonomous creations that can function as replacements for real human labor. I wrote an essay years ago about a company that claimed to have a block laying robot that would revolutionize the construction trades. They had put out a great little two minute video showcasing its performance and I immediately questioned the reality of something that dependent upon electronics and microcircuitry using something as unforgiving as water and mortar in the open air where most of its work would be found. I wondered about what was required to deliver, assemble and install the required track it travelled on, what the effects of hardening cement would have on its components over time, who would have to program and system test it to ensure its functioning, how it would be protected in unexpected weather, who would feed it block and mix the mortar, how much the transportation would cost to get it on site, etc. At each step I saw no actual labor savings, but rather, an additional cadre of workers assigned to support the system. Where once a single mason and laborer could handle the construction of a block wall, now you had a programmer, the technicians required to maintain it, the people to deliver, set up and then take down and reload the equipment, as well as the same laborer to mix cement and load the block. The only thing missing would have been the mason. I called the company several times to inquire about pricing, but no one ever returned my calls within the week I was researching and writing the piece, so I assumed it wasn’t actually a marketable product, but more a pitch for venture capital. That company still does not produce these robots for commercial use at this time.
As I drove home, I thought about that difficult little patch of ground and the possible solutions for maintaining it. The first, obviously, would be to hire a young guy to weed whip the slope a couple of times a month for $15-$20 an hour for an annual cost of a couple of hundred bucks. Second, and the one the owners of the nursing home had decided upon was to buy a $3,000 robot and pay their salaried superintendent to run it ineffectively and do a sub-optimal job or to simply plant that slope with a a perennial ground cover for a one-time cost of a few hundred dollars and a weeding or two thereafter.
This is the part of the I don’t believe in robots position that I mean when I say that. On a factory floor doing a repetitive task, perfect tool for the job. Out in the wild doing something cheaper and better than human labor and experience, subprime at best.
I understand people who do believe in them and I have heard them talk about robotics in terms that do not adequately describe the attenuating circumstances that come along with robotics in our era. It is a great narrative but in reality, it is a pretty poor substitute.
Off to do some more human carpentry.
In the meantime-
Tweet
Continue reading...
[ H/T The Burning Platform ]
The past couple of weeks I’ve been helping a friend two towns over with a little carpentry. The route takes me through one of the larger towns in our region and as I was waiting for a light at my last turn I looked up on the embankment and noticed a robot lawn mower. I’ve never seen one before, but it was pretty obvious what it was and I was able to find it easily online to check out the specs.
Amazon.com: Mammotion LUBA 2 AWD 5000HX Robot Lawn Mower with 4G, Reception 1.25 Acres, Max. 1.48 Acres, All-Wheel-Drive for 80% Slope, UltraSense AI Vision & RTK Automatic Edge Mapping, 2.2″-4.0″ Cutting Height : Patio, Lawn & Garden
The mower was stalled on the slope and you could clearly see where it had been trying to get traction by all the soil that had been churned up around it. It wasn’t moving and based on my casual observation it wasn’t moving anytime soon. The grade on that slope was 20 degrees, easy and it wasn’t the sort of hillside you’d want to mow on foot unless you were very young and athletic. There wasn’t actually much in the way of grass growing there anyway, a mix of switchgrass and little bluestem mixed with some other common weeds from the sidewalk at the bottom to the parking lot at top of the hill. I decided to circle back around so I could take a photo of it to show anyone who wanted to see it the next time I went on one of my Kaczynski rants. By the time I got back to that intersection I noticed that the robot had an operator, a guy in khaki pants with one of those key chains attached to his belt loop that indicated some sort of maintenance role for the nursing home beyond the parking lot. He was holding a controller looking somewhat perplexed while the robot twitched and stalled in place. I was at a red lights, o I took my photo and then, on impulse I called out to the guy working the controls-
Robot fail!
He looked at me with a dour expression and replied, I like it. And then the light turned green and I pulled out into traffic. By the time I circled back the second time and drove past, I looked up and noticed that the robot still hadn’t moved.
I finished my work that afternoon around 4:30 and headed home, beat and sore from my work but glad to have been of help. When I got to the intersection where I’d seen the robot earlier, I had completely forgotten about it. There were a few more patches of churned up dirt where it had apparently run into the same stalling troubles it had experienced earlier, and there were several large patches where it had clearly not been able to mow at all, but it was gone and so was the operator.
As I have written so many times in the past, I don’t believe in robots. Not that they exist, at least in the Ford assembly plant/Roomba vacuum level, but as fully autonomous creations that can function as replacements for real human labor. I wrote an essay years ago about a company that claimed to have a block laying robot that would revolutionize the construction trades. They had put out a great little two minute video showcasing its performance and I immediately questioned the reality of something that dependent upon electronics and microcircuitry using something as unforgiving as water and mortar in the open air where most of its work would be found. I wondered about what was required to deliver, assemble and install the required track it travelled on, what the effects of hardening cement would have on its components over time, who would have to program and system test it to ensure its functioning, how it would be protected in unexpected weather, who would feed it block and mix the mortar, how much the transportation would cost to get it on site, etc. At each step I saw no actual labor savings, but rather, an additional cadre of workers assigned to support the system. Where once a single mason and laborer could handle the construction of a block wall, now you had a programmer, the technicians required to maintain it, the people to deliver, set up and then take down and reload the equipment, as well as the same laborer to mix cement and load the block. The only thing missing would have been the mason. I called the company several times to inquire about pricing, but no one ever returned my calls within the week I was researching and writing the piece, so I assumed it wasn’t actually a marketable product, but more a pitch for venture capital. That company still does not produce these robots for commercial use at this time.
As I drove home, I thought about that difficult little patch of ground and the possible solutions for maintaining it. The first, obviously, would be to hire a young guy to weed whip the slope a couple of times a month for $15-$20 an hour for an annual cost of a couple of hundred bucks. Second, and the one the owners of the nursing home had decided upon was to buy a $3,000 robot and pay their salaried superintendent to run it ineffectively and do a sub-optimal job or to simply plant that slope with a a perennial ground cover for a one-time cost of a few hundred dollars and a weeding or two thereafter.
This is the part of the I don’t believe in robots position that I mean when I say that. On a factory floor doing a repetitive task, perfect tool for the job. Out in the wild doing something cheaper and better than human labor and experience, subprime at best.
I understand people who do believe in them and I have heard them talk about robotics in terms that do not adequately describe the attenuating circumstances that come along with robotics in our era. It is a great narrative but in reality, it is a pretty poor substitute.
Off to do some more human carpentry.
In the meantime-
Tweet
Continue reading...
[ H/T The Burning Platform ]