Festivus came early to Babylon

AP22291480904406.jpg


Festivus came early to Babylon, New York. More than two dozen residents showed up at a Nov. 5 town meeting over a budget that would raise town taxes nearly 6% and again pierce the state’s 2% cap. The plan also carried a 29% raise for the supervisor. Supervisor Rich Schaffer called that figure a ceiling and cited a 1% average yearly raise. The town then revised the budget to drop the raises, and Schaffer will cut his own salary to $120,000, telling Newsday, “Message received.”

Taxpayers who show up can win, and I’m glad they did. They won the cheap fight, though. The costly one takes place at the bargaining table, where public-employee unions and elected officials fix the budget long before a resident reaches the microphone. I’ve spent more than 30 years in investment management, and a money manager who asked for a 29% raise would end up with redemptions.

In 2024, the town proposed a 9.9% levy increase and blamed salaries and health insurance premiums. For 2027, Newsday reports projected increases of about $1.7 million for health insurance and $664,509 for pensions. The raise Schaffer dropped was about $36,000. Voters notice that in a headline, and hardly anyone reads the benefit math.

Rush Limbaugh had a name for what follows. On June 27, 2018, he called the union and Democratic Party arrangement a very clever money laundering operation. As he laid it out, taxpayer money keeps public payrolls full, dues come out of those paychecks, and a share lands in Democratic campaigns. A fair reader should test it on a spreadsheet, where the loop looks worse than it does on the radio.

The Supreme Court ruled that same day. In Janus v. AFSCME, a 5-4 majority held that compelling nonmembers to pay public-sector union fees violates the First Amendment, reasoning that bargaining over public money is speech on matters of public concern. Franklin Roosevelt saw the problem decades earlier. In 1937, he told a federal employee union leader that collective bargaining, “as usually understood, cannot be transplanted into the public service.” He wrote about federal workers, yet the logic carries to town halls. When the patron saint of the New Deal sounds like a Heritage Foundation fellow, the other side has a branding problem.

Concentrated power compounds the risk. Schaffer has also chaired the Suffolk County Democratic Committee since 2000. The FBI has confirmed it is working with state investigators on allegations about his September party election, including claims he offered money to secure attendance and votes. He denies wrongdoing and calls the claims baseless. Allegations are not convictions, and these concern a party election rather than the budget. My point is structural: one person holds the county party chair and the town checkbook. I live in California, so I recognize one-party calculus on sight.

Union defenders have a fair argument: the workers who guard the beaches and plow the roads earn their pay. I agree. My objection targets the table, not the workers. The people spending the money did not earn it, and the people paying for it never get a seat.

PRIDE OR PREJUDICE IN THE CLASSROOM

Start with pay. An independent commission should set elected officials’ salaries, with a freeze in any year the town overrides the tax cap. Next, the board should publish the full multiyear cost of every union contract, wages, health insurance, and pensions included, in plain English before it votes. Sunlight is the best disinfectant, and Babylon just ran a pilot program. Lastly, unions should obtain annual written consent before dues fund political activity, which extends the logic of Janus from nonmembers to members, and no town supervisor should also run a county party.

Marcus Aurelius observed that what harms the swarm cannot benefit the bee. Public servants are bees too, and good ones deserve fair pay. Taxpayers make up the swarm. Babylon’s residents pinned the raise, a respectable Festivus feat of strength. The tax bill remains the tougher opponent. The board votes Wednesday, so bring a bigger crowd and a calculator.

Jay Rogers is a financial professional with more than 30 years of experience in private equity, private credit, hedge funds, and wealth management. He writes about issues in finance, constitutional law, national security, human nature, and public policy.

Continue reading...

[ H/T Washington Examiner ]

Comments

There are no comments to display
Back
Top