Democrats are already searching for their next national message, and one idea now circulating for 2028 is about as subtle as a campaign hat.
The pitch: soften the party’s image, promise a calmer political culture and, in the words attached to the strategy, “Make America Nice Again.”
Yes, that acronym is exactly what it looks like.
Axios reported that some Democratic leaders believe voters will want a more optimistic, decent and less exhausting kind of politics once President Donald Trump leaves the stage. The outlet found that the idea already competes with a rival theory that the party’s midterm success came from matching Trump’s confrontational style rather than retreating from it.
The emerging argument is that Americans are tired of constant outrage and would respond to a candidate who promises to turn down the temperature.
The report identified a genuine split rather than a finished party platform. Governors, senators-elect and likely presidential contenders are offering very different lessons from the midterms.
Some want decency to become the brand. Others believe Democrats won because they finally matched Trump’s aggression and should keep doing it.
The slogan emerged from that unresolved argument, not from a formal campaign launch. It is being tested as a possible answer to years of political fatigue while the same potential candidates compete to prove who can fight hardest.
Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg offered one version of that message. He said the end of the Trump era should open the door to a politics in which checking the news makes people’s blood pressure go down instead of up.
The Denver gathering became an early stage for the party’s ambitious figures to test those competing approaches.
Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro made a similar case, saying voters are ready for what he called an end to “ruthless chaos and cruelty.”
That sounds pleasant enough. The problem for Democrats is that several of their most visible figures are simultaneously arguing for the opposite approach.
California Governor Gavin Newsom has spent much of the Trump era presenting himself as the Democrat most willing to throw punches. His message is not “nice.” It is that Democrats should fight fire with fire.
Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed was even more direct at a Democratic gathering in Denver. According to the Axios account, he said that if someone wants to drag him into the mud, he will take that person there and “choke them out.”
His current public message is just as blunt.
That is quite a long way from morning news that lowers your blood pressure.
The split was visible at the party’s post-midterm conference in Denver. The Associated Press described Democrats using the meeting to argue over what comes next after the midterms, with ambitious figures testing different ways to define the party and convert a successful election into a durable governing coalition.
The gathering brought together newly elected officials and possible 2028 candidates while the party was still celebrating its gains. Their speeches showed that winning did not settle the strategic argument.
Instead, the results gave every faction evidence for its preferred approach: economic populism, ideological combat, moderation or a return to civility.
That leaves the party with an immediate governing test as well as a future branding exercise. Voters will be able to compare the promise of decency with how Democrats actually use their new power.
Some newly elected Democrats leaned heavily into decency. Kansas Senator-elect Adam Hamilton has said he wants a productive relationship with Republican Senator Jerry Moran.
Ohio Governor-elect Amy Acton made basic decency part of her campaign.
Texas Senator-elect James Talarico has repeatedly framed politics around loving one’s neighbor, even while warning that modern politics has become a blood sport.
But even candidates who sold themselves as decent and unifying still ran negative advertisements when the race tightened. That is the reality of campaigns: consultants may rebrand the tone, but power is still power.
The proposed slogan also reveals something Democrats may not want to admit. After years of treating “Make America Great Again” as toxic, some in the party now apparently believe its structure is too effective to ignore.
They are borrowing a cadence and conceding that a simple, memorable promise can outperform a 40-page policy platform.
The bigger question is whether voters will buy the makeover.
A party cannot spend years rewarding its loudest activists, accusing its opponents of threatening democracy and celebrating scorched-earth tactics, then flip a switch and become the national party of niceness.
Democrats have plenty of time before 2028 to settle the argument. But they will eventually have to choose.
Do they want the calming politics Buttigieg is selling, or the bare-knuckle politics Newsom and El-Sayed are practicing?
Right now, “Make America Nice Again” sounds less like a strategy than a slogan searching for a party willing to live by it.
This is a Guest Post from our friends over at 100 Percent Fed Up. View the original article here.
Continue reading...
[ H/T WLT Report ]