Zach Bryan looked out over 73,538 people, a Gillette Stadium record, and told us he hoped this was the best night of our lives. I was in the crowd. He had already made it impossible.
The night had everything a night like that is supposed to have. A family caravan for the fans among us. A lead singer with an infectious smile, piercing eyes, and a band loud enough to shake the place. Guys and girls screaming at the top of their lungs. Gigantic video boards with GILLETTE stretched across the top. At one point the screens flashed video of Matthew McConaughey, the kind of borrowed cool a stadium act uses when it wants to feel like more than a concert. Zach saluted police and veterans. I noticed that. But it couldn’t erase the shirt.
Sleeves cut off, the way he always wears them: FREE PALESTINE across the chest, and under it a pine tree and the words AN APPEAL TO HEAVEN. Half the band was not in the costume. That mattered to me. It meant the choice was not the price of admission for everyone on the stage. It was his.
He didn’t explain it. He didn’t have to.
The garment was the statement.
And the setting mattered. This was Gillette Stadium, home of the New England Patriots. Super Bowl banners hung overhead. Championship history surrounded us. This was Robert Kraft’s building.
Just last month, Kraft publicly objected when another performer, Macklemore, promoted the same “Free Palestine” messaging and banned him from the premises. The shirt was not incidental. It was deliberate.
And the two lines on the shirt do not belong together.
“An Appeal to Heaven” is John Locke’s phrase and George Washington’s flag, a claim that when earthly authority becomes tyranny, men may appeal to a law above it. It is a symbol of ordered liberty, of rights that do not depend on the mob. In Massachusetts it even has a local history, a maritime flag from the Revolution.
Free Palestine, in the form that has traveled through Western stadiums since Oct. 7, 2023, has meant something else: the erasure of the Jewish state, or at minimum the deliberate forgetting of how this war began. It has become a slogan often detached from the atrocities that set these events in motion.
One slogan asks heaven to judge tyrants. The other too often asks a crowd to forget what was done in that slogan’s name.
Printing them on the same piece of cotton is not nuance. It is a contradiction worn as a flex.
The calendar made it worse.
Saturday night sat four days from the anniversary.
On the morning of Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas cut the sound at the Nova music festival outside Re’im and murdered hundreds of Israelis there, most of them young, most of them civilians, while kidnapping dozens more into Gaza. They had come for a night of music. The attack on Nova was the deadliest single episode of that day’s massacre.
To wear “Free Palestine” under stadium lights, four days from that anniversary, is to ask a crowd of music fans not to think about what was done to another crowd that had gathered for the exact same reason.
I could hear us.
I could not stop thinking about them.
I was surrounded by all the symbols of a great American stadium experience, and yet I could not stop thinking about another crowd at another concert that never made it home.
None of this required me to pretend the songs were bad.
They aren’t.
That is the trap.
A voice that can fill a football stadium can still be only a voice. Talent is not morality. It is not wisdom. Success is not a moral credential. I can grant the craft and refuse the claim. Those are not the same motion.
He had the right to wear it. That is the easy part, and it should be said plainly, including by someone who was there and hated it.
As the famous line commonly attributed to Voltaire puts it: “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.” Scholars dispute whether Voltaire ever wrote those exact words. The principle remains sound.
Free speech is not the issue.
The point was never that Zach Bryan lacks the right to wear the shirt. The point is that the rest of us retain the right to judge it.
For a long time the culture pretended otherwise, that the artist who speaks is brave by definition and that the audience’s job is to clap or leave.
That bargain is broken.
Silence now reads as assent, and cancelation reads as panic.
What remains is the harder thing, and the more necessary thing: engagement.
Hear the song.
Reject the argument.
Listen to the artist.
Challenge the slogan.
Argue the merits in public without pretending a celebrity becomes wise because he can sell out Foxborough.
I did not need Zach Bryan to share my politics to have a good night. I needed the night to be only a night.
It was not.
And it would be obscene to set my disappointment beside what happened at Nova, as if those experiences belonged in the same category.
Nobody in Foxborough was hunted off a festival ground.
Nobody in Foxborough was murdered for attending a concert.
Nobody in Foxborough was dragged into tunnels.
We went home.
They did not.
Continue reading...
[ H/T The Daily Signal ]
