The City of Charlotte is asking a judge to throw out the wrongful-death claims brought by the family of Iryna Zarutska, the 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee who was fatally stabbed aboard a CATS light-rail train.
Charlotte’s central argument is blunt: the city says governmental immunity shields it from being held liable for the security failures alleged by Zarutska’s estate.
No judge has granted that request, and the case has not been dismissed. Charlotte is trying to get out of the lawsuit before the family’s claims can proceed against it.
Zarutska was killed on August 22, 2025, while riding the LYNX Blue Line home from work.
Prosecutors say Decarlos Brown attacked her without warning. He is accused in separate state and federal cases and has not been convicted.
The lawsuit was filed on August 21 by Frank Scott Haskell, Zarutska’s uncle and the administrator of her estate. It names both Charlotte and the city’s transit-security contractor as defendants.
The estate’s 29-page complaint says Zarutska was a fare-paying passenger using Charlotte’s public transit system after work. It argues that CATS accepted her fare and owed her the highest degree of care owed by a common carrier.
The filing alleges that Charlotte knew the Blue Line and Charlotte Transportation Center had a history of violent crime. It claims the city still failed to provide adequate fare enforcement, physical barriers, security staffing, monitoring, deployment, and passenger warnings.
The estate further alleges that Brown boarded without paying and that no checkpoint or fare-enforcement officer stopped him. It says stronger enforcement and a visible security presence could have kept him off the train or interrupted the attack.
Those claims remain allegations that Charlotte and the security contractor may contest. The city denies ignoring passenger safety and denies that any action or omission by Charlotte legally caused Zarutska’s death.
According to WBTV’s review of the filing, Charlotte submitted its dismissal motion on Monday, November 16. The city raised ten defenses, with governmental immunity at the center of its effort to exit the case.
Charlotte’s position is that operating and policing public transit are governmental functions protected from this type of damages claim. The city also disputes the estate’s negligence allegations and says its decisions did not legally cause the attack.
If the judge accepts all of Charlotte’s arguments, the claims against the city could end before a trial. If only part of the motion succeeds, some claims could be narrowed while others continue.
The private security contractor is a separate defendant, so a ruling for Charlotte would not automatically resolve every part of the lawsuit. The next major step belongs to the judge, not the city.
WSOC-TV reports that Charlotte also invoked the public-duty doctrine and argued that the complaint fails to state a legally valid claim. Those are separate legal paths to the same immediate result: dismissal of the estate’s claims against the city.
The city also challenges the estate’s foreseeability theory. Charlotte argues that crime elsewhere on the transit system does not, by itself, establish that officials should have anticipated this specific attack on this specific train.
That point goes directly at the family’s argument that earlier violence and known security gaps made the danger predictable. The estate says the pattern demanded stronger safeguards; Charlotte says the pattern does not create legal responsibility for Brown’s alleged act.
The motion therefore asks the judge to decide both whether immunity applies and whether the complaint has alleged enough to keep the city in court. Neither side’s characterization is a final finding of fact.
The public anger is easy to understand. Riders pay fares and are told the system is secure, yet the estate alleges that the safeguards Charlotte chose were nowhere near enough when Zarutska needed them.
But the legal question is narrower than the moral one. The judge must decide whether immunity and the other doctrines Charlotte raised actually bar the estate’s claims at this stage.
If the motion is granted in full, the claims against Charlotte would be dismissed. Claims against the private security contractor could still follow a separate legal path.
The filing also comes while Brown’s criminal cases remain unresolved. A federal judge found him incompetent to stand trial in June and ordered treatment intended to restore competency.
Charlotte can argue that the law protects it. Zarutska’s family can argue that a fare-charging transit operator cannot escape scrutiny when its alleged security failures end in a passenger’s death.
Now a judge will decide whether the family gets to make that case against the city at all.
We’ll keep you updated as the court rules.
Continue reading...
[ H/T WLT Report ]