BREAKING: Appeals Court Rules House Violated Constitution With COVID-Era Proxy Voting

cory-wilson-proxy-ruling-1600x900-1.jpg

A deeply divided federal appeals court has just delivered a major constitutional rebuke to the COVID-era House of Representatives.

In a 9-8 en banc decision, the Fifth Circuit ruled that the House violated the Constitution when it counted absent members as present through proxy voting to establish a quorum for a massive federal spending bill.

The ruling strikes directly at a practice adopted under former Speaker Nancy Pelosi during the pandemic and used to pass the $1.7 trillion Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023.

But the immediate legal remedy is narrower than the headline may suggest: the court left in place an injunction preventing the federal government from enforcing one provision of that package, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, against the State of Texas.

The decision quickly drew national attention:

NEW: In a 9-8 vote, the en banc Fifth Circuit held that the House of Representatives violated the Constitution by counting absent members toward a quorum through proxy voting when passing a major 2023 spending law. pic.twitter.com/mHFphy5ZtH

— SCOTUS Wire (@scotus_wire) November 20, 2026

The Fifth Circuit’s official opinion says the Constitution’s Quorum Clause requires members of Congress to be physically present when their presence is needed to establish a majority. Judge Cory Wilson, a Trump appointee, wrote that proxy “presence” does not count and that the House cannot use its internal rules to evade a constitutional limit on its power.

The majority relied on the text of Article I, the original understanding of the clause and congressional practice stretching back to the Founding. It pointed to the Constitution’s express power to compel the attendance of absent members, reasoning that the language would make little sense if an absent lawmaker could simply be deemed present.

The court also rejected the government’s argument that judges were required to accept the House’s declaration that a quorum existed. The underlying facts were not disputed: the House reached its claimed quorum only by counting proxies, leaving the court to decide the legal meaning of the Constitution.

That distinction allowed the majority to avoid a factual investigation into Congress’s records while still reviewing whether the procedure itself crossed a constitutional line. The opinion affirmed the district court’s judgment and preserved the injunction won by Texas.

The numbers behind the ruling are extraordinary.

The House recorded 225 votes in favor, 201 against and one present when it approved the final version of the spending package on December 23, 2022. Of the 427 members who recorded a vote, 226 participated by proxy.

That meant fewer than a majority of the serving House members were physically in the chamber for the vote:

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the House allowed absent members to vote and be counted toward a quorum by proxy. When it passed the 2023 spending law, 226 members voted by proxy, leaving fewer than a majority physically present.

— SCOTUS Wire (@scotus_wire) November 20, 2026

The dispute began with House Resolution 965, which the Democratic-controlled chamber adopted in May 2020 as an emergency response to COVID-19. It allowed one member to cast another member’s vote and permitted the absent member to be counted as present for purposes of establishing a quorum.

The proxy system continued into the next Congress and remained available when the House took up the year-end spending package in December 2022. Representative Chip Roy challenged the lack of a physical quorum on the floor, but the presiding officer answered that the House rules treated proxy participants as present.

The Fifth Circuit said that answer could not settle the constitutional question. While each chamber has broad power to determine its own procedures, those procedures still must remain within the limits imposed by the Constitution.

The majority emphasized that the decision is about using proxies to create a quorum, not every possible form of proxy voting. The court did not decide whether a member could vote by proxy when a constitutionally sufficient number of lawmakers were already physically present.

Texas brought the challenge after the spending package became law.

The Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 funded the federal government and carried numerous separate provisions, including the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. Texas argued that the House never validly passed the package because it lacked a physical quorum when the decisive vote occurred.

A federal district judge agreed and blocked the federal government from enforcing the pregnancy-accommodation law against Texas. A three-judge Fifth Circuit panel later reversed that judgment, but the full appeals court vacated the panel decision and reheard the dispute en banc.

Friday’s 9-8 ruling restores the district court’s result. It does not erase the entire appropriations law, claw back federal spending or automatically invalidate every provision included in the package.

The relief remains tied to Texas and the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act because that was the injury and remedy properly before the court. Any broader challenge would have to confront standing, remedies, timing and other major legal questions that this case did not resolve.

That limitation is crucial:

The ruling does not invalidate the entire 2023 spending law or categorically prohibit proxy voting. Instead, it leaves in place an injunction preventing the federal government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas.

— SCOTUS Wire (@scotus_wire) November 20, 2026

The eight dissenting judges warned that the majority was interfering with the House’s constitutional authority to govern its own proceedings.

Judge James Graves argued that the Constitution gives Congress broad discretion over its internal procedures and does not categorically require physical presence for a quorum. Judge Catharina Haynes filed a separate dissent, underscoring just how closely divided the full court was.

The dissent also pressed the majority on the potential consequences for the remainder of the spending package. If the House lacked a valid quorum, the dissenters asked, why would that logic stop with one provision rather than threaten the entire law?

The majority answered by focusing on the limited relief Texas actually sought and had standing to pursue. That keeps the immediate judgment narrow even though the constitutional reasoning could influence future disputes over laws passed under the same proxy-quorum rule.

The case is State of Texas v. Blanche, and the federal government can seek review from the Supreme Court.

For now, however, the full Fifth Circuit has drawn a bright constitutional line: Congress may write its own procedural rules, but it cannot declare absent lawmakers present when the Constitution requires a real quorum.

That is a major victory for the principle that members of Congress should have to show up before their presence can be used to pass the nation’s laws.

This is a Guest Post from our friends over at WLTReport. View the original article here.

The post BREAKING: Appeals Court Rules House Violated Constitution With COVID-Era Proxy Voting appeared first on 100PercentFedUp.com.

Continue reading...

[H/T 100PercentFedUp]

Comments

There are no comments to display
Back
Top