America has the freest press in the G7

AP26125697706648.jpg


It is farcical to suggest, as the Paris-based Reporters Without Borders organization does, that the United States has the least press freedom of any G7 nation.

This matters because the organization’s annual “World Press Freedom Index” is making waves for its assertion that the U.S. is sorely lacking in media freedom. Semafor noted last week that the index now puts the U.S. below the other G7 nations of Germany, the United Kingdom, Canada, France, Italy, and Japan. As I noted on X, this is a wholly unserious assertion. The World Press Freedom Index has three immediate problems.

WHY CHINESE DELEGATIONS ARE SO RUDE

First, it overweighs anti-press rhetoric against the far more consequential role of anti-press government policy. This leads to a pretense in which President Donald Trump’s anti-press screeds are judged as systemically repressing press freedom, rather than as simply frustrating for the press.

Second, the index negatively penalizes corporate media ownership while rewarding publicly financed press activity. This has an outsize negative weighting against the U.S. media model, which coalesces corporate media alongside a growing array of media startups such as podcasts, etc.

Third, the index suffers from a direct conflict of interest. Its funding is sourced both through nongovernmental organizations, but also via generous grants from the European Union and member nations. It has an incentive to privilege governments that fund it.

There are many other problems. For one, considering that the index is based primarily on questionnaires sent to journalists and academics in each country, its results indicate that too many American journalists/academics have an exceptionally inflated sense of the difficulty they face. And while there are some extraordinarily courageous American journalists, the vast majority of us suffer nothing compared to the likes of journalists just south of the border.

This is not to say that the American media doesn’t face undue challenges.

Trump’s recent ban on CNN, MS Now, and Politico’s access to the White House was indeed illegal, for example. But a media lawsuit quickly saw access restored. The ban underlined both Trump’s sad disdain for the First Amendment, but also the judiciary’s power to defend media rights under the law. Again, it is shameful that an American president has so little regard for the right of the press to speak freely. Still, the American constitutional system fundamentally restrains Trump’s worst impulses.

Moreover, on the foundational issue: On the right of the press to investigate, report, or comment robustly, the U.S. stands far superior to other G7 nations.

Take national security issues. France, Germany, Italy, and the U.K. all retain laws to hold journalists criminally culpable for publishing classified information from a source. In the U.S., only those leaking classified information are prosecuted (unless the journalist is actively supporting a theft of classified information). And while American journalists can be imprisoned for failing to disclose sources, that imprisonment tends to be short-lived and highly beneficial for one’s career!

The six other G7 nations also all retain defamation laws which prioritize public figures (high-profile individuals) over the public interest in scrutiny of power. The measure of these restrictions is extraordinary when compared to U.S. laws.

In Italy, defamation by the media falls under the criminal code. Amid the proliferation of sole-operated media outlets/podcasts, etc., these laws carry significant negative impacts beyond the traditional press and onto society more generally. In practice, they deter media coverage on crucial matters such as embedded corruption. Consider how, prior to Russia’s February 2022 invasion of Ukraine, British journalists struggled to cover the corruption of Russian oligarchs who had established residency in the U.K.

The U.S. provides far more extensive protections for press coverage on public figures. Under the Supreme Court’s landmark New York Times v. Sullivan case, public figures suing a media outlet for defamation must prove that the outlet either knew what they asserted was factually untrue, or that they had serious doubts as to the truth of their claims. In contrast, other G7 members welcome press intimidation by some of the worst people in the world.

Take Russian oligarch and mobster, Alisher Usmanov. Usmanov deploys expensive legions of public relations specialists and lawyers to deter and punish negative reporting on his person. France last week yielded to extortion from Usmanov’s friend, the similarly corrupt Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, and removed EU sanctions on Usmanov. Yet, had European journalists had the freedom to speak the truth about Usmanov (as American journalists such as myself do), it would have been far more difficult for France to justify its sanctions relief.

Still not persuaded? Well, contemplate the fact that in France, Germany, Italy, and Japan it is also unlawful to issue vitriolic insults against public figures. These laws can be enforced even by prison sentences. French and Italian officials are particularly notorious for filing complaints against the media in this regard.

There’s more.

The U.K., Canada, France, Germany, and Italy all also place significant restrictions on hate speech. Befitting its deference to (and effective financially purchased ownership by) the EU political tradition, Reporters Without Borders does not view these restrictions as undue infringements on media freedom. Unlike the U.S. legal system’s deference to the freedom of the speaker over the emotions of the subject, European laws adopt wide-ranging and often highly subjective hate speech restrictions. At the margin, these laws deter vigorous media commentary.

DO NEW PENTAGON UFO SPHERE VIDEOS SHOW ALIEN DRONES?

These hate speech laws don’t begin and end with simple fines or slaps on the wrist. They are often enforced with significant judicial sanctions. In the U.K., for example, a media commentator deemed to have engaged in hate speech might expect a longer prison sentence than a prolific pedophile.

The U.S. is imperfect. But the notion that America isn’t one of the world’s freest environments for press activity is patently absurd. And when it comes to press freedom in the G7, the U.S. manifestly leads the way.

Continue reading...

[ H/T Washington Examiner ]

Comments

There are no comments to display
Back
Top